Selecting Tenth Edition Week 3

Posted in Feature on June 28, 2006

By magicthegathering.com Staff

Last week's card vs. card was hotly debated on the message boards, and a vote that some thought would (or should) be a blowout came in even closer than Hurricane vs. Earthquake, showing once again that just because a card doesn't work for some players doesn't mean there aren't others that love it.


Paladin en-Vec wins against Auriok Champion!
     
Paladin en-Vec 4469 51.5%
Auriok Champion 4214 48.5%
Totals 8683 100%

Card Vote #3

This week it's up to you to choose between biggie size beaters for one of green's creature slots.

Click here to reveal your choice.



Comments from Aaron Forsythe

Because we have a three-pronged vote this week, Matt and I are dragging fellow developer Mike Turian into the mix to defend, ahem, Erhnam Djinn. Best of luck there, Mike.

Troll Ascetic is one of those creatures that redefines what a creature is capable of. Not only is he costed aggressively for his size—three power for three mana is a great deal… not only does he regenerate, making sure he never dies in combat… but he has the best kind of untargetability we've ever used in the game. “Can't be targeted by opponents” is such an absurdly greedy ability. YOU get to enchant and equip your guy, but your opponent is completely stymied. Talk about the best of both worlds…

Troll Ascetic was a powerhouse when Mirrodin was in Standard and he's still a staple in Extended. He's probably neck-and-neck with Eternal Witness for the best three-mana green creature ever printed. How could you not want this guy back.

Comments from Mike Turian

Bring on Erhnam Djinn! Straight out of Arabian Nights, Judgment, Chronicles and the Beatdown Box Set, the meanest green creature to ever see print in Magic needs your vote to make it into Tenth Edition.

Erhnam Djinn belongs in 10th because he represents the ideal green creature. Give one of your opponent's dorks forestwalk while you beat them over the head with that beefy 4/5 creature. Magic players from any era remember playing with Erhnam Djinn. Whether it was Erhnam-Geddon or Erhnam and Burn'em, Erhnam Djinn has represented green for ten years. Show him the respect this icon of Magic deserves! Like Serra Angel, Sengir Vampire, Mahamoti Djinn, or Shivan Dragon, let every kid that's never seen green's iconic fatty crack one in a booster and be wowed by the most awesome green creature in Magic: The Gathering, the classic, Erhnam Djinn!

Comments from Matt Place

I love it when the best big ground creature is green. Often the top ground pounders in standard are creatures with drawbacks. And more often than not, those creatures are red or black. Arc-Slogger, Goblin Goon, Yukora, the Prisoner and to some extent Phyrexian Scuta and Grinning Demon are good examples of this. I am a huge fan of the green creatures that claim the title of “best ground pounder” and do so in a “green way” and without disadvantages. Ravenous Baloth and Troll Ascetic both have the potential to claim that title in any standard format (sorry Mike!), but I would prefer to see Ravenous Baloth win this vote.

Ravenous Baloth is my pick for 10th Edition because it allows green to fulfill its rightful role in standard, and that is to DEMOLISH weenie decks. I like to see control decks lose to the red/green or mono red beatdown decks, but if the weenie decks are also beating green medium size creatures something is wrong. Like Loxodon Hierarch, Ravenous Baloth swings the match heavily in favor of the green deck when facing weenie beats and that is the way it should be.

Overall I am a big fan of both the Troll and the Baloth, but with Loxodon Hierarch rotating out of standard about the same Tenth Edition is released, we need to make sure green is still the color that punishes weenie beatdown decks with its beefier beaters.

Basic Land Art: Block #2

Last week you voted on the lands of Ravnica, and there were two clear favorites!

Plains

Richard Wright 3500 40.3%
Stephan Martiniere 2797 32.2%
Christopher Moeller 1826 21.0%
Anthony S. Waters 563 6.5%
Totals 8683 100.0%

Island

Stephan Martiniere 3403 39.2%
Richard Wright 2511 28.9%
Christopher Moeller 2262 26.1%
Anthony S. Waters 507 5.8%
Totals 8683 100.0%

Swamp

Richard Wright 2706 31.2%
Stephan Martiniere 2594 29.9%
Christopher Moeller 2343 27.0%
Anthony S. Waters 1043 12.0%
Totals 8683 100.0%

Mountain

Stephan Martiniere 2721 31.3%
Christopher Moeller 2636 30.3%
Richard Wright 2111 24.3%
Anthony S. Waters 1218 14.0%
Totals 8683 100.0%

Forest

Stephan Martiniere 4153 47.8%
Anthony S. Waters 2014 23.2%
Christopher Moeller 1632 18.8%
Richard Wright 884 10.2%
Totals 8683 100.0%

As far as Ravnica was concerned anyway, Stephan Martiniere and Richard Wright were clearly king. What happens this time around? The block with the second-most votes for basic land art was Invsaion!

So, just like last week, for each basic land type, you'll pick your favorite. This time around, the top Plains, Island, Swamp, Mountain, and Forest from Invasion will have their art appear in Tenth Edition. Here are the pieces you'll be choosing from.

Plains


John Avon

Ben Thompson

D. J. Cleland-Hura

Scott Bailey

Island


Tony Szczudlo

John Avon

Terese Nielsen

Darrell Riche

Swamp


Ron Spencer 1

Rob Alexander 1

Rob Alexander 2

Ron Spencer 2

Mountain


Matt Cavotta

Jeff Miracola

Glen Angus

Scott Bailey

Forest


John Avon

Alan Pollack 1

Alan Pollack 2

Glen Angus

Go Vote!

To vote in the polls, you'll need to use your message boards account. If you don't have one yet, you can go here to create one. Once you've done that, or if you already have an account, you're all set. You've got until the site updates Sunday night to get your vote in, so click the link below to launch the polling page and go make your voice heard!

Latest Feature Articles

FEATURE

A Closer Look at the Next Three FNM Promos by, Nicholas Wolfram

Blake already announced the Friday Night Magic promos through June back in January, but we felt like you may want a closer look at the new art for the next three promos, so here you go! ...

Learn More

FEATURE

Magic Story Podcast: Mark Winters by, Blake Rasmussen

This week, we're on episode six of six of the Magic Story Podcast, and we're joined by Mark Winters, Magic senior art director and the art director for Aether Revolt. He's here to talk ab...

Learn More

Articles

Articles

Feature Archive

Consult the archives for more articles!

See All

We use cookies on this site to enhance your user experience. By clicking any link on this page or by clicking Yes, you are giving your consent for us to set cookies. (Learn more about cookies)

No, I want to find out more