Once upon a time, long long ago, I evolved the Fun with Fungus theme deck. One of the additions I made to the deck was Coat of Arms. Coat of Arms gave me a way to leverage large quantities of creatures of one type into huge amounts of damage.
Overrun and Coat of Arms are similar in many ways—both let your large hordes of creature turn into huge creatures that deal massive amount of damage in one turn. In today's online metagame, though, Coat of Arms can often be a liability.
For those not familiar with the term metagame, it is a fancy way of saying "the pool of decks that are currently being played a lot in your area." In this case, the area is all of Magic Online's casual room. Everybody and their sister is playing some sort of tribal deck—and this means that Coat of Arms, which pumps both your creatures, and your opponent's creatures, can often be as much of a liability as it is a strength. Overrun, on the other hand, only makes your guys bigger.
The one strength green had was, ironically, that green was usually avoided because it was so weak. This meant that at any given table, if only one or two people were concentrating on building a primarily green deck, they might end up with a really strong deck. If six people are drafting black, and only two people drafting green, the green (split two ways) is going to be stronger than the black (split six ways) even if black is a much stronger color than green.
What's all this have to do with Building on a Budget? Hold on, I'm getting to it! So green was generally the worst of the five colors in straight Tempest draft, but green had one card which everyone feared: Overrun. Overrun was considered one of the most unfair cards printed for Draft—and this was even more the case once Odyssey block came around, Overrun was reprinted, and green was probably the best color in that set for Limited play!
Even to this day, I know how to do Overrun math. 3(X) + Y – Z = Dead, where X is the number of creatures you control, Y is the combined power of those creatures, and Z is the combined toughness of your opponent's creatures. I've played many a game where my opponent (or I) went from 20 life to 0 life in a single swing due to Overrun. Giving all your creatures trample is the key to making this work—otherwise, your opponent can just chump block and go their merry way.
So if I were to build a deck around Overrun, I'd need to keep two facts in mind:
- The more creatures I have in play, the more extra damage I get to do with Overrun (which is a Giant Growth with trample for every creature I control).
- The majority of my deck, if not the entirety of my deck, has to be green, since Overrun has a very strict color requirement ()
Thankfully, the Elves of Standard have many creature token generators. This meant that I could easily fuse the above two goals into one deck, and not hurt for the color requirements. This deck was going to be Standard using Magic Online, meaning that Morningtide is not yet legal. Here's the list I came up with for the deck (with ticket costs per card in parenthesis):
4 Boreal Druid (.2)
3 Gilt-Leaf Ambush
3 Immaculate Magistrate (.5)
4 Imperious Perfect (.5)
4 Llanowar Elves (.2)
3 Lys Alana Huntmaster
3 Scryb Ranger
4 Thelonite Hermit (.5)
1 Wren's Run Packmaster (.5)
3 Yavimaya Dryad
4 Harmonize (1.5)
4 Overrun (.3)
3 Pendelhaven (1.75)
Total Cost: Just about 20 tickets
I also wanted several ways to generate large quantities of token creatures, to cheat on the creature count. Remember—if I have Overrun, every creature I have is going to swing for a minimum of four damage, so it doesn't matter if they are 1/1 tokens or 4/4 tokens—quantity is definitely desired over quantity. Imperious Perfect, the ubiquitous elf generator and lord, was first on the list—he works well with my other mana creatures and other token generators, which are sure to be elves as well. I also wanted Gilt-Leaf Ambush (which could make two elves in one turn), Lys Alana Huntmaster (which benefits from every other elf cast), Wren's Run Packmaster (to generate wolves), and Thelonite Hermit.
I really loved the Hermit in my Saproling deck, and I decided to use him again here. Although this deck isn't Fungus intensive by any means, Thelonite Hermit is a 1/1 that, effectively, puts four 2/2 creatures into play. So:
3X + Y – Z = Dead
3 x (5 creatures) + 9 (power) – Z (toughness of my opponent's creatures) = 24 (damage being dealt with just two cards).
That's not a bad deal.
I also rounded out the deck with Harmonize (to fill my hand after dropping a lot of creatures), Yavimaya Dryad (to jump from one to three to five—Llanowar Elves to Yavimaya Dryad to five mana on the board), and Immaculate Magistrate—which theoretically would give my other Elves huge bodies for just the cost of tapping it.
Game 1: spence72 (Red-Green Elementals)
He gets Incandescent Soulstoke, and makes Nova Chaser (as an 11/3 haste creature) and Timbermare (as a 6/6 haste creature) on consecutive turns, activating a Treetop Village after playing Timbermare on turn five to kill me in two swings.
Game 2: vicious beastie (Mono-Black Control)
She gets Tendrils of Corruption on one of my Elves, but I get Overrun and knock her down to 7. She uses Hypnotic Specter to strip my hand, and then plays Damnation. At five lands, she plays Korlash, Heir to Blackblade, discards two Korlash to go up to nine Swamps, and then drops Loxodon Warhammer to hit me for 12. If you're going to turn the game around, there's not many better ways to do it than going from an empty board to a 12/9 regenerator with trample and lifelink in one turn.
About this time, I'm realizing that my deck really, really needs a way to kill a utility creature. I pretty much was taken apart by both Incandescent Soulstoke and Hypnotic Specter, and if I could have killed either one early, I might have stood a chance to win those two games.
Game 3: tonytanner (White Weenie)
He gets Soltari Priest, Soltari Priest, Serra Avenger, Serra Avenger, and Knight of the Holy Nimbus. I get Llanowar Elves, Yavimaya Dryad, Lys Alana Huntmaster, Gilt-Leaf Ambush, and double Scryb Ranger. The Rangers untap Llanowar Elves twice, and I play Overrun and Imperious Perfect to do 26 points of trample damage the turn before I'm going to die, killing him from 17.
Game 4: varsity171 (Treefolk Elves)
He gets an early Treefolk Harbinger, and follows it with Woodland Changeling, Essence Warden, and Jagged-Scar Archers in following turns. I get a first-turn Boreal Druid, second-turn Imperious Perfect, third-turn face-down Thelonite Hermit and make a 2/2 Elf Warrior, fourth turn unmorph, fifth turn Overrun for 40 trample damage.
Game 5: enigma307 (Mono-Green Dryads)
He gets Dryad Arbor and puts Blanchwood Armor on it, and then gets another Dryad Arbor with Yavimaya Dryad. I get Llanowar Elves and Scryb Ranger, swing in for a few, drop double Yavimaya Dryad, and then play Overrun for the win.
The good news is that Overrun is fannnnntastic, and I'm able to turn games around in a single turn from a certain loss into a crushing win. The bad news is that I realllllly could use a way to kill smaller creatures, and green is pretty short on creature removal spells, no?
Well, it's not the best compared to Seal of Fire, I'll give you that. It's not horrible, though, if you're on a budget and you're playing green. Back in the day, White and Black Weenie decks used to run a card from Fallen Empires called Aeolipile (look it up!). It was a two-mana artifact that cost one mana to use, and it sacrificed to deal 2 damage to target creature or player—in short, a rare version of Moonglove Extract that switched one mana of mana cost for one mana of activation cost.
I had two choices when decided if I wanted Moonglove Extract in my deck—did I want to keep the deck mono-green, or did I want to splash a color? In the end, I would rather give up a little efficiency to gain a lot of consistency. With the amount of green cost for my cards, I wanted to make sure I got all the green mana I needed every game, without the possibility of color screwing myself. What I needed was an early-game way to kill a creature, and Moonglove Extract was just that card—it costs two mana more than Seal of Fire, but it is colorless, usable in my mono-green deck, and fills my need just fine. Why would I disrupt the entire mana base of my deck just to splash four copies of one card (Incinerate? Shock?) that, in the context of what I needed, was only marginally better than Moonglove Extract?
Game 6: icabod99 (Black-Blue Discard)
I get a slow start with Yavimaya Dryad, followed by Llanowar Elves and Scryb Ranger. He plays Thieving Sprite, trades it with the Dryad, and proceeds to evoke Mournwhelk, Makeshift Mannequin on his Mournwhelk (which I kill by targeting with Scryb Ranger), evoke a second Mournwhelk, Nameless Inversion an Imperious Perfect, and Profane Command a Perfect, bringing back his Thieving Sprite.
To stay in this game, I basically hit him for 2 a turn with Scryb Ranger and Llanowar Elves, use Harmonize to keep my hand full, and start getting past his Thieving Sprite with Pendelhaven, once it comes back via Profane Command. Early on I draw an Overrun, and the plan is to make sure I don't discard the Overrun no matter what—this means untapping my Llanowar Elves with Scryb Ranger during icabod99's turn, just to get an extra Forest into my hand to discard! After over a dozen turns, I finally get within Overrun range, and break through past a newly played Mulldrifter.
Game 7: kokeryou (Mono-Green Haste)
He drops Mire Boa and brings double Primal Forcemage on the consecutive turns afterwards. I get Llanowar Elves and double Boreal Druid and use them to get out a quick unmorphed Thelonite Hermit. Kokeryou puts Uktabi Drake onto the board, Giant Growths it, and hits me for 11. On my counterattack, kokeryou blocks my tokens with one of his Primal Forcemages, and then I drop and use Moonglove Extract to kill the other. I get knocked down to 3 before I finally overwhelm kokeryou with sheer numbers thanks to a Lys Alana Huntmaster and an Imperious Perfect.
Game 8: Frank Dead (Green-White Kithkin)
Game 9: CryDoc (Black-White-Green Dragons)
His only play of the game is Search for Tomorrow, and so the game ends on turn five with Thelonite Hermit (unmorphed), four Saprolings, Yavimaya Dryad and Boreal Druid attacking, and Moonglove Extract taking him from 2 to 0 after the attack. After the game, CryDoc tells me that he's playing Dragons—otherwise, all I saw was two Forests, a Plains and a Swamp.
Game 10: nagi100 (Red-Green Snow)
I get a Yavimaya Dryad and a Scryb Ranger, and start hitting him for three a turn. He gets Brooding Saurian, double Phyrexian Ironfoot, and Karplusan Strider, but is held back by my unmorphed Thelonite Hermit and a Lys Alana Huntmaster. Bad news for me though—a main-phase Sulfurous Blast takes out my entire team, and leaves me open to get killed in one swing. Frown town!
Overrun was definitely the key card for this deck, and man-oh-man was it as good in Constructed as I remembered it being in Limited. If you like making your underdog men into the big bullies on the block, definitely pick up this deck and give it a whirl.
This leads me to the Intruder Alarm deck, which also features Elves, but for a much different purpose than attacking for 20! If you recall, I was periodically going to revisit my Extended budget Intruder Alarm / Sprout Swarm deck to play it in the competitive room of Magic Online. After the last time the deck showed up, I made the following changes:
I was tired of getting my face beaten in by my own Forbidden Orchard tokens, so that was straight out. Someone suggested in the forums that the reason my Merfolk Looters died so often was because of how good they were, so I decided to add three more of the same, in the form of Thought Courier. Dryad Arbors came straight in for Forbidden Orchard—they function as a creature that can untap with Intruder Alarm in play, and can combo with Imperious Perfect to make infinite Elves. I also yanked the Vanquishers, and in their place added Islands, to smooth out the mana base now that Orchards were out and more blue cards were in.
Match 1: Dace_tnl (Mind's Desire Storm)
Game 1: I get down Dryad Arbor and Essence Warden and lose both of them to a Pyroclasm, courtesy of Burning Wish. I drop Intruder Alarm and Imperious Perfect, and Dace_tnl tries to combo off, playing Mind's Desire for four. His four cards are two Invasion sac lands, a Chromatic Sphere, and another Burning Wish. He gets Hull Breach with the other Wish and kills my Intruder Alarm, but I have a second Intruder Alarm and draw a concession when I show Sprout Swarm.
Match 2: Kapitan Dymano (Mono-Red Gargadon)
Game 2: I get three Dryad Arbors killed early, but a pair of Essence Wardens gets me close to 30 life before he plays Pyroclasm. We then go back and forth for a long time—he keeps killing my Merfolk Looters / Thought Couriers, and I get Sprout Swarm with fourteen mana to keep from getting hit by his Gargadon and Raiders (which are 5/5). Eventually, he gets down double Gargadon, Raiders, and a Ghitu Encampment, and I can't get enough blockers to stop from being killed.
Match 3: traumkrieger (Mind's Desire Combo)
Game 1: I have the absolute perfect draw: turn one Llanowar Elves, into turn two Utopia Sprawl plus Imperious Perfect, with an Intruder Alarm in hand. He goes first, and he puts down an Invasion sac land turn one, plays another on turn two along with a Simian Spirit Guide and a Burning Wish for Channel the Suns, and then kills me on turn three with Mind's Desire.
Frown town again!
Game 2: He triple mulligans and still beats me, as I have a slow draw this hand.
Merfolk Looter / Thought Courier is great! It allowed me to dig for the cards I needed when I needed them, and they were definitely a strong addition to the deck. In fact, it's been suggested that the Elves leave the deck in favor of Merfolk once Morningtide is legal. While I don't think the Elves would go entirely, a combination of Stonybrook Schoolmaster and Drowner of Secrets would also go infinite with Intruder Alarm.
I don't really have any sideboard against Mind's Desire, or an aggro deck! In all three matches I played, my sideboard was completely useless. I need to find cards that can help me disrupt Mind's Desire decks—they are going to be played all over the place now that the deck finished extremely well at Grand Prix–Vancouver.
See you all next week!