Those of you expecting major changes today are in for a disappointment. I won't be adding green for Sakura-Tribe Elder and Eternal Witness, nor will I be dropping the majority of the Rats to make a Slumbering Tora reanimation deck. I will be talking about these options, though.
See, I like the way this current deck plays. The two things that bother me are 1) getting to five mana for Nighteyes the Desecrator in a deck with twenty-four land and no mana-acceleration, and 2) the presence of Nezumi Cutthroat. Since I most recently added a fourth copy of the Cutthroat, this second point may need some explanation.
Good, but maybe not appropriate?
Nezumi Cutthroat is good in this deck. It allows me to break through creature stalemates, often sneaks a Throat Slitter into play, and, basically, has won me a lot of games almost single-handedly. What bothers me is that it still supports an aggressive Rat strategy rather than a Ratimation strategy. Taking the Cutthroat out scares me because it feels so smooth to draw one, but every time I'm winning with it I feel a little... you know... dirty.
Anyway, those two things that bother me certainly aren't problems that require major alterations. Instead, let's watch these next five games carefully and keep a keen eye for whether my deck is playing like the Ratimation deck it's supposed to be.
Game 26: Monogreen Snakes
Much like my game against Snakes two weeks ago, he had Tangle Asp and a few other blockers while I had Nezumi Cutthroat. Two, actually. I played Ravenous Rats, then Nezumi Bone-Reader to sac my Rats as a way of emptying his hand of scary high-cost Snakes. The result was that my two Cutthroats went the distance while Nekrataal played first-striking defense. The game ended quickly.
One-game analysis: All Cutthroat, no Ratimation. Boo.
Game 27: Monogreen Spirit Aggro
I consider ninjutsu bouncing almost as good as reanimation since it exploits comes-into-play abilities, so that was a satisfying victory. My deck didn't care about weenie rush, concentrating instead on controlling the board and my opponent's hand.
Game 28: White/Green Equip
I was looking at an interesting choice on the second turn between Nezumi Graverobber, Nezumi Cutthroat, and Distress. Then, on my opponent's first turn, he used Steelshaper's Gift for Sword of Light and Shadow. Okay then, easy choice. I Distressed his Sword, seeing a sea of land and two Sakura-Tribe Elders. I drew and played a series of Chittering Rats and Ravenous Rats to eat his hand, then used my Nezumi Graverobber to start eating his graveyard. Just for fun, I started returning my Chittering Rats to hand with two different Throat Slitters so that he played the same turn again and again. I won at eighteen life.
Game 29: White/Blue Kaldra
My opponent was remarkably rude for playing such a cool deck. He used Ethereal Haze and Holy Day to buy him time to set up the pieces of Kaldra, with Fabricate to help his cause. I flipped into Nighteyes the Desecrator right away, then used Chittering Rats and Throat Slitter to deny him a few draws. At six life, he achieved his Kaldra token, but I started my Rat Attack in earnest to dropped him to two with Nezumi Cutthroat on the board, using Zombify on my Chittering Rats to keep up the tempo war. He used Terashi's Grasp on his own (indestructable) equipment to gain four life, then I used Ravenous Rats to get his sole card--Mirror Gallery--out of his hand. He called me lucky and said a bunch of not-very-nice-things as my remaining Rats swarmed in for the win.
That was definitely a win thanks to the Cutthroat, though there was a fair amount of Ratimation shenanigans happening as well. Hmmm...
Game 30: Green/White Arcbound
I'm guessing my opponent used green's “add counter” cards like Battlegrowth in conjunction with Arcbound creatures and maybe a trick or two like Test of Faith. I didn't see much of my opponent's deck, though. In fact, I'm not sure I can appreciate how frustrating it must have been for him in this game. His Arcbound Worker and my Nezumi Cutthroat traded attacks, then his Worker and Arcbound Slith stalled against my flipped Nighteyes the Desecrator. Chittering Rats came into play, then died from blocking, then came back to play, then died from blocking, then came back to play, then died from attacking, then came back to play, then bounced to Throat Slitter, then came back to play. My opponent conceded at that point, not wanting to face drawing the same card for something like the sixth turn in a row. Now that's Ratimation at its finest.
Final analysis: Nezumi Cutthroat is indeed good, but also feels out of place. I should have enough removal against non-black decks without needing an aggressive beater whose only purpose is to be an aggressive beater, right? As a result...
OUT: 4 Nezumi Cutthroat
The question isn't why I'm taking out the Cutthroat, which I've pretty much covered to this point, but what to put in instead. First thing's first:
IN: 1 Swamp
As I said, the deck has no mana acceleration and only twenty-four land. That's a lot of pressure to put on even a mono-colored deck when what it wants to do is reliably reach five mana. In fact, my deck wants more than five mana if it can manage it. Normally I would worry that this twenty-fifth land would result in a lot of mana-flooding, except that I'm also adding...
IN: 2 Sensei's Divining Top
IN: 1 Rend Flesh
I'm highly ambivalent about this final slot. I thought about a fourth Zombify, but I think it would too often get stuck in my hand. I seriously considered a fourth Nekrataal, but it's nice to have instant-speed removal sometimes. Rend Flesh also helps battle against a clear weakness of my deck's, which is against other monoblack decks. The hope is that it not only saves me from dying but can also deposit a creature into an opponent's graveyard for Nighteyes or Ink-Eyes reanimation. As you'll see below in the “Adding Money” section, there are a lot of potential rares I could add to my deck instead of two Rend Flesh (my first choice would probably be Solemn Simulacrum here), but Rend Flesh is a solid addition that will probably save my bacon more often than not.
Ah, it feels good. I've played this deck a lot over the past two weeks, going 27-10 (remember, though, that win-loss records in the Casual Decks room don't mean nearly as much as in the Tournament Practice room). My wins are now much more about Chittering Rats locks and Ratimation than any sort of weenie rush. I've also had an unusual number of Magic Online players message me to say they've been playing the deck in some incarnation or another and loving it. A success!
Or is it?
It's true that Rats have remained a dominant theme in the deck, thanks almost entirely to the fact that I wanted to keep Patron of the Nezumi as part of the deck's nucleus. I probably should have recognized this from the beginning, and either dropped the Patron or owned up to the fact that Rats was going to stay a large part of the deck. I didn't, which may have caused some confusion for people given my stated goals for this experiment. Mea culpa on that one.
The fact that the deck's minor themes have remained doesn't bother me in the least, however. As I said on the Boards, every deck has major and minor themes. The fact that my deck relies on discard, Ninjas, and creature removal to support its reanimation strategy seems not only acceptable but appropriate. It was never my intention to completely weed out the minor themes of the deck, only to elevate one of those minor themes into a primary one.
So have I failed? On one hand, reanimation has transformed from a minor theme to a major theme. On the other hand, the deck is still very much about Rats, so although I neutered the aggressive nature of the deck I didn't really diminish one of the two major themes. I'll let you decide whether this experiment was a success or not, and your feedback on the message boards will help me figure out how to approach the next time I decide to focus on a preconstructed deck's minor themes (because it will happen, I assure you). The good news, I suppose, is that regardless of the minor-major theme issue, the deck is awfully fun to play.
Speculative Sideboard Time!
Right now I think my deck is sitting somewhere in between a deck that is fast enough to take advantage of slower decks and a control deck able to take advantage of more aggressive, creature-based strategies. As a result, I think the sideboard is a good place to push the deck in one direction or another depending on whether I'm facing a slow or fast deck.
Sideboard: 4 Skullsnatcher
Against slow, controllish decks, the Bone-Readers and Rend Fleshes come out for Skullsnatcher. Not only is Skullsnatcher a quick beater, it's also going to recycle Ravenous Rats and Chittering Rats, two cards that are my key to defeating control decks. As a huge added bonus, Skullsnatcher eats graveyards to prevent Eternal Witness, Myr Retriever, reanimation, and other graveyard-reliant strategies.
The particular deck I'm facing will determine which cards come out for Mind Sludge, but usually I think it's going to be Nekrataal. The idea here is that against slower decks my discard and quick weenies are going to be my winning ticket, so I need to drop a few critters, then follow it up with a fifth-turn Mind Sludge. If you have access to Persecute, those could fit into this slot as well.
Sideboard: 2 Eradicate
I'll use the same logic here as I did in my last experiment: “Eternal Witness is a pain. So is Myr Retriever. So is Keiga, the Tide Star. So is Darksteel Colossus. So is Solemn Simulacrum. So are a lot of creatures, actually. In these cases, Eradicate is my friend.”
Sideboard: 3 Echoing Decay
Against creature-based decks, it's often hard to get my creatures unblocked for Ninjas or to get a Throat Slitter through or to keep useless weenies from chump-blocking my Patron of the Nezumi. This is especially true against the green decks rising in popularity that use Beacon of Creation and/or Sosuke's Summons. I also have a hard time against more aggressive monoblack decks. In all of these cases, Echoing Decay is a cheap, effective form of creature removal.
On average, green creatures are more common than white creatures in constructed decks. The reason not to use Slay, though, is that so many of green's creatures--including Sakura-Tribe Elder, Troll Ascetic, and Kodama of the North Tree--are untouchable by spot removal. Instead, I'm using these slots to guard against the many White Weenie decks I've been facing online (remember, sideboards are metagame-dependant).
Sideboard: 1 Nekrataal
As I said last time, for decks susceptible to Nekrataal, he is one awesome creature. If a deck has non-black creatures that I can target, Nekrataal is arguably my most effective and potent way of controlling the board.
Adding Money To The Deck
It turns out that there are exactly four hundred and seventy-three thousand rares you can add to a Ratimation strategy if you want, even when keeping the deck monoblack. My success with the deck thus far should emphasize that these cards are optional to the budget deckbuilder. If you happen to have access to them, though, you may want to consider a few of these Standard gems.
Right now I'm using twenty-five Swamps. Without cards like Corrupt or Nightmare in the deck, however, there's no reason to limit myself to basic land. Use Blinkmoth Nexus for more offense (and a spiffy ninjutsu target) or Shizo, Death's Storehouse to help out Nighteyes, Ink-Eyes, and Patron of the Nezumi.
If I could add another Ink-Eyes or two, I probably would. She is, after all, the Queen of Ratimation.
Beacon of Unrest
As several people on the Message Boards have noted, swapping Zombify out for Beacon of Unrest doesn't slow down the deck a huge amount and gives you the ability to retrieve opposing creatures and artifacts. The extra flexibility of Beacon is certainly worth one more black mana.
I'm not entirely sure what I would take out for Grave Pact, but with my fairly expendable Rats jumping to and from the graveyard, this is a card that could devastate a lot of opponents.
I took out Umezawa's Jitte, but two pieces of equipment seem to fit perfectly with my Ratimation deck. One is Sword of Light and Shadow, which not only gives two great abilities to my deck but also gives me some game against opposing mono-black decks. The second is Scythe of the Wretched, which has some directly-into-play reanimation built into it.
Finally, no reanimation “Adding Money” section would be complete without suggesting that you could find other fatties to drop into your graveyard for reanimation. Kokusho, the Evening Star is the most obvious fattie-addition to the deck, but Triskelion, Duplicant, Nightmare, Fallen Angel, and Phyrexian Plaguelord are all worthy possibilities, not to mention uber-fatties like Darksteel Colossus and Kuro, Pitlord as long as you figure out some way to put them into your graveyard.
Paths Not Taken
For the most part, I'm going to focus on Ratimation variants rather than open up to a wider reanimation theme. The reason is because I think there are a lot of different ways to make a Ratimation deck that are worth considering. If you like Rat's Nest and Nezumi Graverobber but don't feel compelled to follow my lead, maybe one of these options will entice you.
Certainly the most requested direction to take my deck was to add green for Sakura-Tribe Elder and Eternal Witness. These two cards alone amp up the effectiveness of Nighteyes the Desecrator, which may be why I've seen quite a few black/green reanimation decks online. Time of Need can search out your beefy legends. Don't forget that you also have access to Viridian Shaman, Wood Elves, and cards like Elvish Lyrist. Elfimation? It's worth considering.
Kami of Ancient Law is probably the best reason to splash white in a Ratimation deck, though with an active Nighteyes the Desecrator you also have a soft lock against creature decks with Kami of False Hope. I could also see adding white for Aven Cloudchaser, Angel of Mercy, or Staunch Defenders depending on what types of decks your friends tend to play.
At first glance, it doesn't look like red has much to offer Ratimation. After all, its comes-into-play creatures are more likely to hurt you (a la Lava Hounds) than help you. Yet if Umezawa's Jitte or Sword of Fire and Ice truly become ubiquitous in your play group, then it may be worth thinking about Hearth Kami and Frostling as targets for your reanimation, not to mention all of the Shatter-type cards you could use. Shock Troops and Pain Kami sound like fun, too.
The other rare many people requested was Shirei, Shizo's Caretaker. I played two games against Shirei decks with my 1.6 version and in both I stole him from my opponent's graveyard, so I know how much fun this guy can be with Ravenous Rats and Nezumi Bone-Reader. If I was building my deck this way, I would probably drop Patron of the Nezumi and a number of Rats in favor of creatures like Ashen-Skin Zubera, Bottle Gnomes, Maggot Carrier, Leaden Myr, and Triskelion. Splashing green for Sakura-Tribe Elder looks juicy with Shirei, too.
As I said, dropping the Rat aspect of the deck and instead focusing solely on reanimation opens up too many doors to discuss here. I've already talked about Mesmeric Orb and Shirei, two cards that may pull the deck away from Rats. Some of the other fun ideas people have thrown my way include reanimating 1) Spirits, with cards like Slumbering Tora, Lifespinner, and Iname, Death Aspect; 2) artifacts, via Bringer of the White Dawn, Second Sunrise, or some black/Atog strategy, and 3) Zombies, using Lord of the Undead and Gravedigger action.
The basic message from both the “Adding Money” and “Paths Not Taken” sections is that you have a tremendous number of options when focusing on the intersection of Rats and reanimation. It feels like I've hardly scratched the surface in these three articles! If you've made a deck along these lines that you've playtested and would like to crow about, please post it on the Message Boards so we can all have a look.
Save the Rats
Saviors of Kamigawa is now available in stores, and will be available to Magic Online players later this month. When I have access to it online, I'll fire up another poll so that you can choose whether I evolve Critical Mass, Soratami's Wisdom, Spirit Flames, or Truth Seekers. Until then, I'll throw a couple of “Interlude” articles your way in preparation for Saviors' arrival.
That said, it's worth contemplating what Saviors of Kamigawa might have to offer my Ratimation deck. As far as I can tell, five cards would warrant some testing. I'll list them roughly in order from most- to least-likely to find a home in Ratimation.
I don't think this replaces Zombify because it is usually going to be so much slower. I could see a copy or two fitting into the deck to supplement Zombify, though. Later in the game, getting three or more creatures back in hand for the price of one card is an awfully juicy proposition for my Ratimation deck.
Footsteps of the Goryo
The big bummers are that it doesn't give haste to the reanimated creature and that it isn't an instant, so for one more mana I would rather have Zombify. That said, there are many times when bringing Ravenous Rats, Chittering Rats, or Nekrataal back for a turn while I'm waiting for an active Nighteyes the Desecrator makes a lot of sense, especially with Nezumi Bone-Reader on the table. The fact that it's arcane makes splicing a Soulless Revival pretty attractive, too.
It's not a Rat and it's a heck of a lot more expensive than Ravenous Rats for the same effect. The question is whether the bigger body and the chance of reuse is worth Kemuri-Onna sitting towards the top of my deck's manacurve. I'm guessing it isn't worth the expense since the deck is pretty good at discard already, but it's not a completely crazy idea.
Measure of Wickedness
For rares, Kagemaro, First to Suffer seems like a great reset button for a deck using Zombify and/or some of the cards I've listed above. Akuta, Born of Ash is a possibility as well, though I can't see my deck wanting to sacrifice its Swamps for a 3/2 body. Of course, almost any deck might maindeck or sideboard Pithing Needle.
Okay, that's enough speculation for one day. As always, I hope you've enjoyed my preconstructed deck evolution. I haven't even looked at the Saviors precon lists yet, but it's going to be a fun time come the end of June.