At the end of the last column, I mentioned that we wanted to solve two problems for the deck:
Problem #1: Scarblade Elite dies too easily and too often.
This is a good problem to have—it means that people view Scarblade Elite as a threat, and they feel that they must strike him down before he starts going crazy and killing everything the opponent drops. For me, it means that I need to find a way to either keep Scarblade Elite alive, or to bring it back from the dead.
One problem with a reanimation strategy in this deck is that I want my creatures going to the graveyard... as long as I have a Scarblade Elite in play. If Elite is not in play, I want to bring other creatures back to my hand—Nightshade Assassin and Nekrataal have great use if they come into play, kill a creature, die, and then come back again to kill another creature. There is tension between these two, so if I were to go this route, I would not necessarily want to play it as a four-of.
Some ways to keep Scarblade Elite alive, rather than bringing it back from the dead, are to give it shroud (Whispersilk Cloak, Cloak and Dagger),or make it larger (Bad Moon, Gauntlet of Power, Coat of Arms, Door of Destinies). In particular, I like the idea of Door of Destinies—I have a lot of Assassins in this deck, and an incidental of playing them over the course of the game could be making all of my other Assassins into game-ending threats. This would allow me, in addition, to kill the Nightmare slot to focus more on Assassins—if all of my Assassins come into play late-game as 6/5 and 6/6 creatures, it means that I don't have as much need for a card like Nightmare to be a finisher.
Problem #2: I'm not taking advantage of Liliana Vess's second ability.
In order to solve problem #1, I decided to add three cards to the deck—Recover, Door of Destinies, and Profane Command. I added only a single Profane Command to the deck, as it is a more pricy card (4 tickets), but a very powerful one. When playing on a budget, it is very cost prohibitive to buy a four-card set of a card that runs 4 tickets. My budget each column is 30 tickets, so four Profane Commands would run me over half of my budget! However, since I have Liliana Vess in the deck (currently running at about 2.5 tickets), I can effectively run four copies of Profane Command by only having one in my deck—one at four tickets, and three ways to tutor it at 2.5 tickets each.
In order to solve problem #2, check out problem #1! I've added a single Recover and Profane Command to the deck, both of which are situationally useful. In addition, I changed out a single Tendrils of Corruption for a single Consume Spirit—Tendrils is generally great as a reactionary spell, or a way to gain quick life as a combat trick, but it can't kill an opponent. Having a single Consume Spirit lets me give up a little flexability (it is a sorcery, and it gains me 2 life less than Tendrils on average, thanks to the startup cost!) for the ability to outright finish off an opponent late game.
I also decided to add a single Weed-Pruner Poplar, to see how well it works in the deck. It is a higher-cost assassin designed to kill smaller-cost weenies, so I'm not sure how effective it will be—but I'm willing to give it a shot. I also add in a single Mind Shatter (2.5 tickets) as a way to battle decks that have a heavy control element, and a single Cruel Edict as a way to deal with protection-from-Black creatures (such as Whirling Dervish or Chameleon Colossus).
In order to make room for the one-ofs in the deck, I decide that Phyrexian Vault is the card that needs to get reduced down to a one-of—it has been decent so far, but the addition of Graveborn Muse has allowed me to have more card-drawing power than I had initially started with, so I can afford to lose a little of the redundancy offered by the Vault.
In: 3 Door of Destinies, 1 Recover, 1 Consume Spirit, 1 Cruel Edict, 1 Profane Command, 1 Mind Shatter, 1 Weed-Pruner Popular
Out: 2 Nightmare, 2 Moonglove Changeling, 2 Tendrils of Corruption, 2 Phyrexian Vault, 1 Graveborn Muse
Total Ticket Cost: 25 tickets
Game 1: Hioo (Green-Blue-White "Comes into Play" Creatures)
He concedes after knocking me down to zero lands with double Mwonvuli Acid-Moss. However, I have Scarblade Elite on the board with six Assassins in hand, and his attack force was Civic Wayfinder, Masked Admirers and Yavimaya Dryad. I would have been able to start killing off his creatures by discarding down from eight to seven cards each turn, and he would have had to start drawing more threats before I could draw lands. He assumed he had this game won—but I wish he had played it out, because I think that I could have pulled this game out by discarding Assassins until I had all of his creatures dead, and then started playing the lands I drew later.
Record: Does not Count
Game 2: K1_Dna (Five-Color Fog)
I get down a Scarblade Elite, and then drop double Door of Destiny. He gets down Mulldrifter and then double Doomed Necromancer. I drop double Ghostly Changeling, Nightshade Assassin and Graveborn Muse, and start trying to break through his board. He has triple Holy Day and double Pollen Lullaby, making it virtually impossible for me to get through his board. On top of this, he drops Ajani Goldmane and starts gaining 2 life a turn.
He can't do damage to me either, since I have Scarblade Elite and a Phyrexian Vault. I can kill any creature he drops, if I want to. I am drawing three cards a turn (thanks to double Changeling and the Muse), and I have Tendrils of Corruption in hand in case I start getting low in life. I finally draw my game-winner: Mind Shatter! This allows me to strip every last Fog effect out of his hand, and when he doesn't draw one the next turn, he concedes—with double Door on the board, my changelings start at 9/9 and only get larger from there!
Game 3: norinobu_k (Mono-Black Control)
Game 4: psicoloko (White Weenie)
This game progresses fantastically for me—I get a second-turn Elite, a fourth-turn Nekrataal, trade the 'Taal for a Benalish Knight, use the dead 'Taal to kill his Goldmeadow Harrier, drop Graveborn Muse to keep my hand full, and drop Liliana Vess to tutor up an offense—Door of Destinies, and then Assassins to pump my board. He drops Ajani Goldmane, but I just ignore it, let him gain 2 life a turn, and start hitting him for 7-8 damage each swing. Eventually I overcome him.
Game 5: CraigWalsh (Black-Green Treefolk)
I drop Phyrexian Vault (which I seem to draw a lot as a one-of) on turn three, and Door of Destinies on turn four. He drops Leaf-Crowned Elder, which I kill with a (now) 3/2 Nekrataal. He plays Weed-Pruner Poplar, and I get Graveborn Muse. He then uses his Poplar to shrink my Nekrataal, and plays Rootgrapple to send both my 'Taal and my Door of Destinies to the graveyard.
I kill his Poplar back with Cruel Edict, and then drop a Poplar of my own. He drops Orchard Warden, which I shrink to 3/5 with my Poplar, allowing me to kill it with a Consume Spirit for five. This allows me to swing into an empty board, and eventually win thanks to the extra cards drawn by Graveborn Muse.
I haven't been terribly impressed with Weed-Pruner Poplar—every time I've drawn it, it's just pretty much been a 3/3 doof—and that's not great for five mana. My deck is skewing very high on the mana charts (my average mana cost is 3.3, and that doesn't count Tendrils needing extra Swamps, or the in Mind Shatter, Consume Spirit, or Profane Command). Instead of having the Poplar, I decide to add in extra land, to make sure that I can hit a Magic number of four (for Nekrataal / Nightshade Assassin / Door of Destinies) each game.
I used to have a lot more black-mana-intensiveness for my deck, due to Garza's Assassin, Nightmare and Tendrils of Corruption. I used to have ten of these three cards in my deck—now I am down to two (two Tendrils), so having Swamps isn't as important as it once was. Because of all the X spells, having a way to build up mana over the course of a few turns would be great—so I take out three Swamps, and replace the Swamps and the Poplar with four copies of Dreadship Reef (which could also be Molten Slagheap—either would be fine, because all I care about it Black mana). This will enable me to build up "X" mana a lot more easily, allowing for a really game-ending Consume Spirit or Profane Command on the back of Liliana Vess's tutoring ability.
Game 6: bh3ll10m (Black-Red Burn)
He drops Oona's Prowler and uses it to madness out Reckless Wurm on turn three. I drop Scarblade Elite, and he Incinerates it off the board. This allows me to use his Oona's Prowler to madness out my own Nightshade Assassin, killing his Prowler—and then I block his Wurm, stack first-strike damage, and use Nameless Inversion to kill his 4/4 trampler. I follow this up with a Mind Shatter for three, taking out Liliana Vess, Swamp and another card from his hand.
bh3ll10m gets right back in the game by dropping a land and Chandra Nalaar, killing my Nightshade Assassin. He then drops Reckless Wurm, and I use Profane Command kill his Wurm and bring back the Elite, which he promptly also kills with Chandra. I drop Liliana Vess and knock the last card out of his hand on consecutive turns—both times a Tarox Bladewing, while he only has two Mountains on the board (to be fair, I had double Nameless Inversion in my hand, so they were under control).
We go back and forth with Chandra and Liliana—I start tutoring up threats (Graveborn Muse), and he is forced to use Chandra to kill them, keeping him from his ultimate 8-mana blow-me-up ability. I finally draw a Dreadship Reef and start building up counters—and then I use Liliana Vess to grab another Vess, so I can start anew. This gives me enough time to tutor up Consume Spirit, which takes out his seven-counter Chandra, and I then drop back-to-back Graveborn Muses while at 24 life to seal this very long and back-and-forth game!
Game 7: Terrax (Blue-White Merfolk)
He gets down Stonybrook Schoolmaster, and I kill it immediately with Nightshade Assassin. I let a Fallowsage live for a turn, in favor of dropping Door of Destinies. This lets me save a second Assassin for a Drowner of Secrets the following turn, and then a Nameless Inversion plus a Ghostly Changeling for a second Drowner of Secrets the turn after. He gets Wandering Graybeard on the board, but at this point I have a pair of 5/4 first strikers and a 5/5 Shade, which allows me to win in two swings.
Game 8: Difool42 (Black-Red Goblins)
He starts with Knucklebone Witch and Weirding Shaman, but gets stuck on two lands with a third-turn Frogtosser Banneret. I drop Scarblade Elite and kill his Banneret with a Nightshade Assassin, and then drop Ghostly Changeling and Graveborn Muse. He draws more lands, and gets a second Knucklebone Witch and a second Shaman, but I start trading my guys two-for-one thanks to Scarblade Elite, and even though I draw eight straight lands with Muse plus Changeling plus my draw phase, my ninth card is a Nameless Inversion—this allows me to kill his freshly played Wort and a Knucklebone Witch on the same turn with that and my Elite, so my guys can push through for lethal.
Game 9: lung174 (Black-Blue Control)
Game 10: Sunflair (Black-Red Rogues)
I have to double mulligan, and stick with a hand that has two Swamps, two Nightshade Assassins, and a Door of Destinies. He drops a Molten Slagheap and a Mountain, puts a counter on his Slagheap, and uses it the following turn to play Prickly Boggart on turn three. Sunflair ends up without any sources of straight black mana, which allows me to get to eight cards (which isn't for lack of trying to drop a land—I still hadn't drawn one!), and madness out back-to-back Nightshade Assassins—one to kill his first Boggart, and one to kill a replacement one he dropped on turn six. He concedes after failing to draw a land for the fifth turn in a row, whereas I have two lands, another Assassin in hand, two Nameless Inversions, and a draw that will explode the second I get a third land (for double Ghostly Changeling).
Game 11: GusJanitor (Elementals)
He gets two Primal Beyonds, a Vivid land and a Swamp, but he has to evoke double Mulldrifter and an Aethersnipe. I drop double Door of Destinies (both set to Assassin, of course), and then drop triple Nekrataal against an empty board. The first dies to GusJanitor's Nameless Inversion, but the other two end up as 7/6 monstrosities over the course of a couple of turns, and win the game on their own.
Silent Assassins was an amazingly fun deck to play. The Assassins, the tribal theme, being able to grow my guys to large size with Door of Destinies, the control elements, the one-ofs that I could tutor for, and Liliana Vess all worked extremely well together. The deck was potent, powerful, fun to play with, and fun to play against (no games were complete blowouts in either direction), and I would very much recommend playing this deck if you're looking for a good time with some black cards that you probably have around!
Next week: The Great Round Robin Experiment—going beyond what you've seen before!