Solving the Control Conundrum

Posted in Building on a Budget on June 20, 2012

By Jacob Van Lunen

Jacob Van Lunen began playing Magic in 1995. He has participated in organized play at every level of competition and was a member of the winning team at Pro Tour San Diego in 2007, thanks to an innovative draft strategy. As a writer, Van Lunen has had more than three hundred Magic strategy pieces published

ello and welcome back to another edition of Building on a Budget. I've been working on a new deck for Standard over the past two weeks and I'm excited to share it with you guys today! In fact, I'm so excited about this deck that I plan to bring it to a local PTQ this weekend.

Standard is currently dominated by Delver of Secrets decks and the red-green decks that have a slight edge against them. Control decks struggle to compete in a world where many of the most popular threats provide card advantage along with an aggressive clock. A lot of readers have asked me to write about a control deck for the current Standard. I found myself with a problem.

Sorin's Vengeance | Art by Jana Schirmer & Johannes Voss

You can use removal spells to survive and prolong the game, but eventually you'll be ground down byMoorland Haunt or undying creatures. Solving this issue leads you down some crazy paths, and most of them end up being dead ends. I tried everything, even Wall of Tanglecord, and I was just about to give up.

Then it hit me! The control deck needs to end the game before it loses to the aggressive deck's inevitability. It sounds crazy. Everything I know about deck construction and Magic theory makes it uncomfortable. Right now, aggressive decks produce too much card advantage and too many diverse threats for control decks to consistently be able to outcard them in a long game.

So I needed to find a way to end the game quickly. It's not an easy task. I can't use a big creature because I'll just lose to Vapor Snag. One of the hardest parts about deck construction in the current Standard is the Snapcaster Mage/Vapor Snag conundrum. You basically lose the game if you cast a creature that costs more than four mana without an enters-the-battlefield trigger and your opponent has a Snapcaster Mage and Vapor Snag in hand.

Our hands are tied. We're going to need to end the game quickly if we're going to build a competitive control deck for Standard. How can we do this?

Sorin's Vengeance

"Ten you!"

Sorin's Vengeance is a card that hasn't seen a lot of competitive play. It's hard to cast and doesn't affect the board. In the past, I haven't been a big fan of cards like this. I haven't played a "ten you" since Urza's Rage.

However, now is the perfect time to be "tenning" people. Delver lists are cutting counterspells to be more efficient in the mirror and other decks won't be able to race the double Sorin's Vengeance line of play. Sorin's Vengeance is a bulk rare right now and should be easy to get.

It's hard to reliably draw two copies of Sorin's Vengeance, so we're going to need another way to deal our opponent 10 points of damage. Sorin Markov is the perfect answer. You'll be pleasantly surprised the first time the following happens.

They never see it coming.

Sorin Markov is one of the easiest-to-acquire Planeswalkers legal in Standard right now. It shouldn't be an issue getting four copies of him.

Sorin Markov
Solemn Simulacrum

I want to play four copies each of spells that cost six and seven, so my deck needs to be well equipped to ramp its mana very quickly. I thought about including green in the deck, but decided I could ramp just fine with the colorless cards available.

Solemn Simulacrum has become drastically easier to pick up in the past couple months. I haven't had an opportunity to build a deck with this card in some time and I'm happy I'll be able to include it in my newest concoction.

Pristine Talisman does a great job of ramping me while providing valuable defense in a unique form.

Sphere of the Suns functions as a Rampant Growth.

Pristine Talisman
Sphere of the Suns

I'm taking the role of the control player, so I'm going to need efficient spot removal and board-sweeping effects. Black Sun's Zenith is the best option available in the current Standard format. By playing a full set of Black Sun's Zenith we make our deck play like it has an endless number of board sweepers. Black Sun's Zenith shuffles itself back into our deck after we cast it, so we'll always have outs when facing down a serious army of creatures.

Go for the Throat is the best spot-removal spell for our deck. Black Birthing Pod decks are doing well onMagic Online and it's only a matter of time before they become more popular in paper Magic. We want our removal to be efficient in the most common matchups. I'll play a few Doom Blades in my sideboard. These can be swapped in for the Go for the Throats when playing against Tempered Steel, an uncommon opponent, and can be added to the deck in matchups where spot removal is most important.

I need to accrue card advantage and dig to my "ten" spells with more than just Solemn Simulacrum. I thought about adding blue to the deck for Ponder, but decided to show restraint for the sake of budget and mana issues. I decided that Ichor WellspringMycosynth Wellspring, and Phyrexia's Core would be the best ways to keep my hand full in a mono-black control deck.

Single copies of Curse of Death's Hold and Distress round out the deck.

Here's what the deck looks like once we put it all together:

Mono-Black Ten You

The deck has a lot of rares, but the whole thing can be acquired pretty easily on Magic Online. I thought about making it more budget, but all the changes I tried making drastically decreased the power of the deck. I'm currently 7–1 with this in heads-up queues on Magic Online, so I figured I'd give you the actual list. This deck is awesome.

I'm going to share a few of the matches I've played on Magic Online.

I lost the roll and kept SwampPhyrexia's Core,Sphere of the SunsSolemn SimulacrumSorin's VengeancePristine Talisman, and Go for the Throat.

My opponent played a Rootbound Crag and passed the turn. I drew Sorin Markov and played Swamp. My opponent played a Copperline Gorge, castStrangleroot Geist, and attacked. I drew Buried Ruin, played it, and cast Sphere of the Suns. My opponent attacked and cast Blade Splicer. I drewBlack Sun's Zenith, played my land, and castSolemn Simulacrum.

My opponent attacked with everything; I blockedStrangleroot Geist and drew a Swamp, then my opponent cast Huntmaster of the Fells and passed. I drew another Swamp, cast Pristine Talisman, and cast Black Sun's Zenith for 2. My opponent cast Acidic Slime and destroyed my Pristine Talisman, then attacked for 1. I drew Ichor Wellspring, cast Sorin Markov, and used his +2 to destroyAcidic Slime. My opponent cast Primeval Titan and searched up a Kessig Wolf Run and another land, then attacked Sorin for 1 with the Golem and passed the turn. I drew Distress, used Sorin's -3 to make my opponent's life total 10, and cast Sorin's Vengeance for the win.

Sideboarding: -1 Distress, -4 Ichor Wellspring, +1 Barter in Blood, +2 Curse of Death's Hold, +2 Doom Blade

I kept SwampSwampSwampPristine Talisman,Black Sun's ZenithSorin Markov, and Curse of Death's Hold.

My opponent cast Avacyn's Pilgrim and passed the turn. I drew Doom Blade and played my land. My opponent cast Borderland Ranger and passed. I drew Mycosynth Wellspring, cast it, and searched up a Swamp. My opponent attacked for 2 and castHuntmaster of the Fells. I drew Phyrexia's Core, played it, and cast Pristine Talisman. My opponent attacked me for 7 and passed the turn with no play, presumably playing around Black Sun's Zenith; I gained a life on my opponent's endstep. On my upkeep, my opponent's Huntmaster flipped; I drew Curse of Death's Hold and cast it, going up to 11 life.

My opponent cast Strangleroot Geist, attacked me for 7 (leaving me at 4), and passed the turn. I drewSorin Markov, played a Swamp, cast another Curse of Death's Hold and gained 1. My opponent attacked me for 2 and passed the turn. I drew a Solemn Simulacrum, cast Sorin Markov, and gave it +2 to kill the Ravager of the Fells. My opponent played a fourth land and passed with no play.

I drew a Swamp, played it, used Sorin Markov's -3 to put my opponent at 10 and cast Solemn Simulacrum. My opponent passed. I used Phyrexia's Core to grab another land with my Mycosynth Wellspring. I drew another Solemn Simulacrum, used Sorin's +2 to put my opponent at 8, attacked for 2 with Solemn Simulacrum, and cast another one. My opponent cast Blade Splicer and got a 1/1 Golem. I attacked with both Solemns and my opponent chump-blocked one. I used Sorin's +2 to put my opponent at 2, who drew and conceded next turn.

I won the roll and kept SwampPhyrexia's Core,Go for the ThroatPristine TalismanSorin MarkovSorin's Vengeance, and Distress.

I played a swamp and passed. My opponent castDelver of Secrets and passed back. I drew anotherPhyrexia's Core and cast Go for the Throat on the Delver. My opponent cast Gitaxian Probe thenSnapcaster Mage to flash back the Gitaxian Probe. I drew Black Sun's Zenith, played my land, and cast Pristine Talisman. My opponent attacked for 2, cast Geist of Saint Traft, and passed the turn—I gained a life. On my turn, I drew a Swamp, castBlack Sun's Zenith for 2, and played my land. My opponent played a land and passed.

I drew Pristine Talisman and cast Distress. My opponent responded with Restoration Angel then revealed DismemberVapor SnagMana LeakGlacial Fortress, and Gut Shot. I took the Mana Leak and cast Pristine Talisman. My opponent attacked for 3, cast Geist of Saint Traft, and passed the turn—I gained another life. I drew a Swamp, played it, and cast Sorin Markov, then used the -3 to make my opponent's life total 10. My opponent attacked, destroying Sorin and dealing me 7. I drew and castSorin's Vengeance.

Sideboarding: -1 Curse of Death's Hold, -4 Mycosynth Wellspring, +1 Barter in Blood, +2Distress, +2 Doom Blade

I went to six cards and kept SwampSwamp,SwampPhyrexia's CoreDoom Blade, andSolemn Simulacrum.

My opponent played a Glacial Fortress and passed. I drew Barter in Blood, played my land and passed. My opponent cast Ponder, chose to shuffle, played Seachrome Coast, and cast another Ponder. I drew Sphere of the Suns and cast it. My opponent cast Geist of Saint Traft. I drew Distress and cast Solemn Simulacrum. My opponent played a land and passed. I drew Ichor Wellspring, played my land, and cast Distress; my opponent responded with Dissipate. I cast Ichor Wellspring and drew Solemn Simulacrum. My opponent played a land and passed again; I usedPhyrexia's Core to draw another card, which wasSorin's Vengeance. I drew a Swamp for my turn, played it, cast Solemn Simulacrum, and found another land. My opponent cast Snapcaster Mage, flashed back a Ponder, cast Ponder, and played a land.

I drew a Swamp, played it, and cast Sorin Markov with the mana to pay for Mana Leak; he resolved and I used his +2 to kill Snapcaster Mage. My opponent attacked Sorin with Geist of Saint Traft and the token; I blocked with both Solemn Simulacrums and my opponent chose to kill one, allowing me to draw a Swamp. My opponent cast another Geist of Saint Traft and passed the turn. I drew and castDistress, taking Dissipate and leaving my opponent with just Mana Leak. I then attacked for two, castBarter in Blood with the mana to pay for leak, and used Sorin's +2. My opponent cast a third Geist of Saint Traft and passed. I used Sorin's -3 and cast Sorin's Vengeance with enough to pay for the leak, and that was that.

The deck has performed very well for me in testing. I strongly recommend putting it together for your Friday Night Magic this week. The major issue with control is the card advantage available viaSnapcaster Mage and Strangleroot Geist, but this deck does a very nice job of fixing that by ending the game quickly when it needs to.

Hit the forums with comments or questions! Be sure to tune in next week for an M13 preview.

Happy Brewing!

Latest Building on a Budget Articles

Daily MTG

June 27, 2012

War Falcon by, Jacob Van Lunen

The Magic 2013 core set is going to be on the shelves of your local game shop in less than three weeks. Many powerful cards have already been announced. I can't begin to explain how excit...

Learn More

Daily MTG

June 20, 2012

Solving the Control Conundrum by, Jacob Van Lunen

Hello and welcome back to another edition of Building on a Budget. I've been working on a new deck for Standard over the past two weeks and I'm excited to share it with you guys today! I...

Learn More



Building on a Budget Archive

Consult the archives for more articles!

See All