The Experiment Must Go On

Posted in Command Tower on June 13, 2013

Creating a Commander deck from scratch can be tough, but even just changing a deck you already have can be hard. When you're talking about sixty, seventy, or even more unique cards the options can be daunting.

That's what we were faced with two weeks ago when we gathered together the submissions for a Melek, Izzet Paragon Commander deck built from many of your suggestions.

Melek, Community Paragon

Download Arena Decklist

It's a Melek deck that elicited mixed reactions, exactly as I had hoped. We asked ourselves a straightforward question: What simple changes would you make to this deck to improve it? (Alternatively, what's wrong with this deck and what would you do differently?) Some of you answered that you would wouldn't change much, and that you loved the deck.

Great. Stop here and skip to this week's prompt at the bottom, unless seeing how others did change perfection is something that still interests you.

For most of you, there were plenty of tweaks, changes, clarifications, and adjustments you'd make yourselves. Even many of you who liked the deck still shared some changes you'd apply. Today, we'll run down a lot of your feedback and apply what we can to turn the dials on this Melek deck all the way to eleven.

    Code Swaps

The most common way you considered changes to the deck was in direct swaps of cards. Take out something so there's room for something else. And the most common swaps were with the lands: Our initial pass was almost all basic lands, which leaves a lot of room to play with, and Boris shared:

You asked in the article "Melek, Commander Paragon" what I should improve to the deck. First of all, let me tell you that I really like how it looks!

However, the one thing that strikes me as odd is the mana base: So many basics? Here's what I would add:

That's it. Good job, I enjoyed the read!

Melek really likes to see an instant or sorcery on top of our deck. Without getting into the raw statistics of the matter, it takes removing more than a couple lands from our library to significantly reduce the odds of seeing one on top, but the fact fetch lands shuffle your library is handy, as Boris noted with Madblind Mountain. Desolate Lighthouse is a land any Izzet can appreciate, and including lands that become creatures is one way to help us gather our mana and defend our turf when we have fewer creatures than other decks.

Matthew had a different group of lands in mind:

One simple change I would make to this deck would be the land base of the deck. Cards like Izzet Guildgate, Izzet Boilerworks, and Steam Vents can give you access to both red and blue mana, letting you cast spells more freely. Cycling lands such as Forgotten Cave and Lonely Sandbar allow you to draw cards more freely while changing the top card for cheap, while Reliquary Tower allows you to keep all the cards you draw between slinging spells left and right. I would also increase the amount of lands in the deck by one or two, as I feel thirty-four is a bit too little for red and blue decks.

So where do we make room for these lands? Jason pointed a few weaker choices:

Nivix, Aerie of the Firemind is useless when you have Melek, as it removes the top card and still forces you to pay the mana cost. Try Halimar Depths instead.

Scrivener/Anarchist/Izzet Chronarch are too expensive for a copy deck. You have access to enough good spells already without needing to recur them for five mana each.

Izzet Guildmage can only copy four spells in the deck, as it currently stands. Just plain chuck him.

For fun tricks, Divert is incredibly good when copied, and when Reroute is included, most combos stop working.

Add Mass Mutiny.

Well, those are my suggestions. Nice emailing you!

Making room for a little more mana is an idea several of you brought up, and between Jason and Matthew's feedback we find enough room to make it happen. (If you're wondering exactly which cards are getting swapped around there's a handy table at the end of this article so you can see everyone's feedback at work!)

Aaron had even more switches to decrease the creature count and increase the spell count:

The Melek, Community Paragon deck is overloaded with ways to manipulate instants and sorceries at the expense of actual spells. The deck only has twenty-three instants and sorceries at the moment but it should have at least twice as many for Melek to be reliable. We can fix some of this by replacing permanents with spells that share a similar role.

While some of these have already been swapped to lands, it's always up to you to change things the way you'd prefer. I hedged toward more lands since that was the most common piece of feedback. Aaron's addition of more spells was common for others as well, such as what Andrés suggested:

I was looking at the Melek list, and the first thing I thought was that there is no clear way to win. So, I'd change the following:



Pact of the Titan + Djinn Illuminatus + Nivmagus Elemental means infinite counters of the Elemental (also add Fervor for additional wins). Besides that, I think extra turns should be a theme in the deck and drawing should be maximized as much as possible. The only additional change I'd make would be to add some nonbasic lands.

I'm almost out of words, so see ya! And great article.

Converting creatures that care about spells into spells that Melek can care about pushes things further into our spell-based plan. While extra turns are a thing of beauty, taking all of the turns is a quick way to make friends unfriend you. Instead of cutting Call the Skybreaker (a spell!) for Beacon of Tomorrows, I decided to add my own change by preventing it.

But don't take just my word for it. Bradley said it, too:

While there are a couple of suggestions I have for improving the deck itself, I want make a suggestion when it comes to making card choices for your deck, in general. Melek gives you power—free spells with double the output. But remember that with great power comes great responsibility.

If you're going to supercharge instants/sorceries, don't let it be of effects that aren't actually fun for the group. Taking an extra turn is only fun for YOU. The more extra turns you take, the more turns and time that are solely dedicated to pleasing you. You become a fun vampire, draining the enjoyment from the rest of your group.

I speak from experience. I took ten extra turns once with Melek. I hated what became of the game and its players as I took my extra turns. I vowed to never take extra turns with Melek ever again.

So there you have it: A sample size of two.

Two was a common number for summarizing things that were wrong, as Ray shared:

The main two problems I see with this deck are a lack of focus and over repetition. I understand in Commander it is important to be able to get what you want and having multiple ways to do that is good, but in a deck with this much fixing, it's not necessary. So I would take out Vedalken Orrery and Leyline of Anticipation because I think Hypersonic Dragon will do fine and we aren't running that many sorceries that will be bombs at instant speed. Also I'm taking out Kiln Fiend, Wee Dragonauts, Nivix Cyclops, and Nivmagus Elemental because they are aggro creatures, and this deck is not going to win with creatures, it will win with spells. With all the copying going on, I personally would play Bribery to use my opponents' threats against them, and maybe grab some stormy stuff like Empty the Warrens or Temporal Fissure for defense.

Ray brings up several cards we've already swapped out, but exchanging Vedalken Orrery and Leyline of Anticipation for instants or sorceries is still on theme. Bribery is a common enough card in Commander that it's no surprise to see it, but Temporal Fissure is something of a different flavor. Clearing away or at least slowing down everyone else a few turns is one way to give Melek more time to do his thing.

Oren chimed in on the instant and sorcery theme too:

There are two things that need to change concerning the Melek deck we've been constructing thus far.

First: Far, far too many of the instants and sorceries in the deck don't have enough of a significant effect on the game. Library manipulation is fine (and very necessary), and copy effects have their place, but the deck needs more heavy hitters like Mind's Desire, Time Spiral, and Wheel of Fortune, and fewer cards like Index or Eyes of the Watcher.

Second: Kiln Fiend, Nivix Cyclops, and Wee Dragonauts are not nearly powerful enough creatures, especially because they don't trigger their bonuses when Melek copies. If that's our deck's focus, make instants and sorceries the way the deck wins, not lackluster creatures that probably can't attack profitably anyway.

If we're looking to make use of storm and cast a series of copies of spells, Mind's Desire is one way to get even more spells from the top. With Melek out... it's like our own Epic Experiment come to life.

    Context is King

Not all feedback came from one-for-one swaps of cards. Many of you provided the context of what you'd change but left it open for how to see it through. Will summed up what most of the changes above drove at:

I think the Community Melek deck could use two main tweaks.

First, the deck simply needs three or four more lands so Melek can reliably come out and we can cast our big spells consistently.

Second, while there are a lot of cards that love having spells cast, there are only about eight big spells that can start to win a game. I would remove some of the cards that like multiple spells per turn and instead just tune the deck to library manipulation, mana, and awesome spells.

In fact, there was so much feedback that even with plenty of editing (of my own words) I couldn't fit everything in. The common themes that cross all of the "missing feedback" were:

  • Lowering the mana curve for our Melek, Izzet Paragon deck. That is, making the deck feel and play faster.
  • Adding more "big effect" instant and sorceries. Creatures aren't what Melek should be trying to use.
  • More nonbasic lands should be included. The total number should be increased, too.

Fortunately, all these of these points are covered, in some fashion, by the changes we did use:

Original CardChange Suggested byNew Card
Magus of the FutureAndrésRal Zarek
Hypersonic Dragon
Djinn Illuminatus
Call the Skybreaker(Adam kept!)
Nivmagus ElementalRayBribery
Kiln FiendAndrésPact of the Titan
Nivix CyclopsAndrésStroke of Genius
Wee DragonautsAndrésMerchant Scroll
Sakashima the Impostor
Stolen Identity
Rite of Replication
Echo Mage
Chandra, the Firebrand
Epic Experiment
Increasing Vengeance
Dual CastingAndrésPonder
Wild Ricochet
Uyo, Silent Prophet
Nivix Guildmage
Izzet GuildmageMatthew/JasonReliquary Tower
Cloven Casting
Cast Through Time
Eye of the StormAndrésPreordain
Scroll Rack
Serum Visions
Invoke the Firemind
Mystic Speculation
Azure MageAndrésWalk the Aeons
Sensei's Divining Top
IndexOrenMind's Desire
Izzet Charm
Eyes of the Watcher
Darksteel PendantAaronForesee
Cryptic AnnelidAaronMagma Jet
Reality Strobe
Mystical Tutor
ScrivenerMatthew/JasonForgotten Cave
AnarchistMatthew/JasonIzzet Boilerworks
Izzet ChronarchMatthew/JasonLonely Sandbar
Izzet Cluestone
Izzet Signet
Izzet Keyrune
Braid of FireAaronSeething Song
Nivix, Aerie of the FiremindJasonHalimar Depths
Mana Matrix
Arcane Melee
Goblin Electromancer
Darksteel Ingot
Worn Powerstone
Mind Stone
Comet Storm
Grab the ReinsAndrésTime Warp
Leyline of AnticipationRayTemporal Fissure
Vedalken OrreryAaronQuicken
Possibility Storm
Time Stretch
12 Island
10 Mountain
MountainBorisMadblind Mountain
MountainBorisDesolate Lighthouse
IslandBorisSteam Vents
MountainBorisIzzet Guildgate
IslandBorisSulfur Falls
MountainBorisTerramorphic Expanse
IslandBorisEvolving Wilds
MountainBorisGhost Quarter
IslandBorisMishra's Factory
MountainBorisGhitu Encampment
IslandBorisFaerie Conclave

Put together, our now community Melek build looks like this:

Melek, Community Paragon (Take 2)

Download Arena Decklist

Remember: The only perfect Commander deck is the one you enjoy most, so don't worry if you'd change even more about this. Just update it how you'd like and go for it!

Next week, we'll look at how you start to build decks, but there's a related topic I think we should consider too: What's the most fun part of building a Commander deck?

  • Feedback via email
  • 100 word limit to answer the question
  • Name and email required (non-personal information to be used in column)

What you enjoy most about building a deck, and why you feel that way, is one approach to highlighting the many ways you can easily pile up all the cards you need. And if you find the number of cards daunting, having a tip sheet of things to consider is a surefire way to focus on what you want to add next in ways you may not have even considered yet.

But first, we have to get started. See you next week!

Adam StyborskiAdam Styborski
Email Adam
Author Archive
Serious Fun Archive

Adam "Stybs" Styborski joined in 2009 to take over Serious Fun, before switching over to begin Command Tower in 2013. With his passion for Commander and community inclusion, you'll find plenty of opportunity each week to share your thoughts about everyone's favorite casual format.

Latest Command Tower Articles


January 7, 2016

Doubling Down by, Adam Styborski

Making mana is a fundamental part of Magic. While we've come a long way from the first booster packs running an Island in the rare slot (lands really are that important!), it hasn't been ...

Learn More


December 31, 2015

Allied Command(er) by, Adam Styborski

War never changes, but Magic does. There's always something new around the corner, like the wonderful wave of awesome incoming with Oath of the Gatewatch. As a Commander aficionado, I'm c...

Learn More



Command Tower Archive

Consult the archives for more articles!

See All