There were so many possibilities when it came to Fire Week. I thought about doing Burning Cinder Fury of Crimson Chaos Fire or Skyfire Kirin. I thought a lot about Burn decks (if ever there was a week I could do that, surely Fire Week is it right?) and started laughing to myself in Beavis and Butthead fashion about “Fire! Fire!” In the end, the pop-culture geek in me was done in by a movie trailer for the upcoming Fantastic Four movie and I chose Flames of the Blood Hand.
Flames of the Blood Hand is one of those simple spells that has a job and does it well. It's an efficient damage dealer all by its lonesome, and it answers two of the problems that plague red damage spells: prevention and life gain. Flames of the Blood Hand will have none of that.
The efficiency of damage is certainly a big deal, a powerful twist on good ol' straight-forward burn. Firebolt can deal 4 damage as well, but it takes twice as much mana and is a sorcery to boot. Tricks aside, Flames of the Blood Hand and Pulse of the Forge are about as efficient a bit of burn as you can point at an opponent right now, per card and mana. This comes into play the more damage that you run in your deck. Essentially, the damage begins to cascade into something far more important – the ever approaching 0 life total of your opponent.
Take this deck from the Extended Season for Philadelphia:
If we pretend that they just burn the other player every turn, you can have a turn sequence like this:
Turn 1 – Seal of Fire (18)
Turn 2 – Volcanic Hammer (15)
Turn 3 – Flames of the Blood Hand (11)
Turn 4 – Blistering Firecat (4)
Of course, your opponent is likely to resist you, but when you have a deck like the one that is built here by Jody Godin, every little burn spell becomes all that much more powerful because you have other efficient burn spells. My former Wednesday co-columnist Mike Flores wrote an excellent article about this entitled The Philosophy of Fire. I really recommend reading it.
A lot of cards that I look at are very specifically about how you can use Card X with Card Y and Bam! Crazy/powerful/clever/cool Effect Z pops out of the works. One of the things with a card like Flames of the Blood Hand is that it is essentially a very responsive card with respect to the environment. Yes, you use it to actively hit your opponent's head, but it doesn't do anything to interact with most of the cards that you are planning on using, rather it interacts with what your opponent is going to be doing.
Let's relook at that initial burn sequence and imagine a game between Jody and Brian. (The decks are from different eras, but this still works as a great example.)
Turn 1 – Seal of Fire (18) – Brian does nothing
Turn 2 – Volcanic Hammer (15) – Brian does nothing
Turn 3 – Flames of the Blood Hand (11) – Brian counters (makes that 15!)
Turn 4 – Blistering Firecat (
4 8) – Brian casts Meditate at the end of opponent's turn (up to 10 cards)
Turn 5 – Blistering Firecat again! (1) – Brian draws a land, lays it, casts Gerrard's Wisdom and gains 18 life! Hand sizes, Jody 2, Brian 7 after discarding
But let's change the order of spells and have Turn 3 save that Flames of the Blood Hand for later. If you simply leave the mana open on Turn 5 for the Flames of the Blood Hand, you'd not only be dealing four damage, but you'd be preventing a lifegain of around 18. To get the same 22 life swing from Pulse of the Forge (a card I would generally call stronger by far than Flames of the Blood Hand), you'd have to spend around 15 mana for it.
Here we can see an illustration of something important. First of all, by preventing life gain, you can actually accomplish the equivalent of a lot more virtual damage than the card might otherwise imply. This means that there is a home for this card in a damage-heavy deck. At the same time, though, you want to be careful about when you cast the card. If you have to worry about life gain, saving Flames of the Blood Hand for the appropriate moment is pretty important. In Extended tournaments, one place where Flames of the Blood Hand ended up showing up was in the sideboard of burn-heavy Red Deck Wins as a massive counter to the Life deck (a combo deck able to generate arbitrarily high life totals), but it could have been used in any deck that expected to get in a lot of massive damage quickly, but would lose to the Life combo; all you needed was a very splashable access to one red mana.
The unpreventable portion of the card is another very important thing to remember. A lot of decks expect to be able to survive through some form of prevention, whether it is Circle of Protection: Red or Sphere of Law. Flames of the Blood Hand can't be prevented, so all you have to plan on doing is attempting to get someone within range of a Flames and you don't have to worry about scary sideboard cards like those. I used Lightning Surge as a Burning Wish target in several decks for this very ability.
A few bells and whistles
The Richard Garfield, PHDs: Both of the Phelddagrifs have an activated ability that grants the opponent life. Well, not if you have something to say about it.
Fiery Justice: This Ice Age burn spell can do a very efficient 5 damage for only 3 mana. Unfortunately, it lets your opponent gain 5 life for the favor. But, it doesn't have to…
Game of Chaos: Break out your Krark's Thumbs. Playing a Game of Chaos with your opponent under a Flames of the Blood Hand means that your opponent could be taking a bit of damage. Get a Thumb in there too and watch the pain really go to town.
There are a couple of other similar examples, but you get the idea. Flames of the Blood Hand really isn't a card for tricks. Think of it more like red's version of Counterspell or Disenchant for the cards that red really cares about stopping.
For this week's deck, I have a modified version of one of the Block Decks that Magic Genius Ben Dempsey and I kicked around for Pro-Tour Philadelphia. In the end, we discarded this deck because of some massive weaknesses to White Weenie (especially Blessed Breath) and mediocre performance against Snakes, but the deck was very good against much of the rest of the field.
The deck went through probably about a million versions, but they all had some very important things in common: they could deal a lot of damage with very few cards. Flames of the Blood Hand becomes a lot better if you can expect to have an opponent at low life, and this deck packed enough burn that even if you were doing things to their creatures you could still hit them low.
Initially, the Flames of the Blood Hand hopped in there as a potential answer to the big problem of Kokusho being joined by a second Kokusho for the life gain, but there was more to it than that: occasionally you could score a nice life swing from a bad Umezawa's Jitte player gaining life all at once (rather than letting each activation resolve), and even if you only stopped one activation from mattering, you still hit them for effectively 6 life.
In the end, we decided that a losing record to White Weenie and a 50/50 Snake match-up wasn't all that hot, and we tried out different decks. I didn't end up winning the Last Chance Qualifier, so I took my Rat Deck Wins to tear up the Grand Prix Trials, and Ben took a black Snakes deck to the Pro Tour and picked up a couple of hundred dollars. Still, though, I wonder if he wouldn't have made more packing Flames of the Blood Hand.
Some Final Words on the Challenge
I've already received several hundred submissions for Tortured Existence and decks to abuse it. If you're looking to get in on the action, the deadline for your decklist and comments is June 3rd. I'm going to reiterate a couple of the things I'm looking for.
- A deck that shows how the card is good. Even if the card plays a supporting role in your deck, it still needs to be good at what it does in the deck.
- The deck uses the card well. Wild Mongrel is a great card, but it isn't very good in a Bottomless Pit deck.
- Your comments explain why Tortured Existence was in the deck.
- If you use multiple decklists, each decklist shows off a different aspect of the card.
- Your deck or idea is original. I have already seen a lot of overlap on good ideas, so if you'd like to be showcased, be clever.
- As always, the early bird gets the worm – if I can't decide between submissions based on other merits, the decision goes to the early submitter.
I hope you've been enjoying Fire Week. See you again next week with the results of the Reader Challenge!