Iname, Fist of the Corrupted

Posted in Feature on October 9, 2004

By John Carter

Send your rules questions to Magic Rules Manager John Carter. Can't find the answer to your question somewhere else? Maybe he's already answered it! Try the Saturday School Searchable Rules Database.

Q: Although they have different 'subnames', Iname, Life Aspect and Iname, Death Aspect technically have the same name and would axe each other due to the new Legendary rule. Is this right? --Hyrum T.

Iname, Life Aspect
Iname, Death Aspect

A: No, their names are different. For example, the green Iname is named “Iname, Life Aspect”, not just “Iname”. Though the Champions names may be flavored differently than in past sets, we still take the entire contents of that upper left corner [CR 202.1] - the intervening comma doesn't delineate the name.

*Extra* For more on Inane, check out his origin story. Iname is just the latest in a line of Legendary creatures that evolve over time such as Ertai, Wizard Adept / Ertai, the Corrupted and Kamahl, Pit Fighter / Kamahl, Fist of Krosa.

Q: Say you attack with Wicked Akuba, and they take it. Can you pay 8 black mana and make them lose 8 life? --Jonathan

A: Yes, once the Akuba's dealt damage to a player, you can sink as much black mana into the ability as you have (assuming they're still targetable). By comparison, cards like Pit Imp do have a limit, and Dragon Whelp has a drawback if you go over a limit.

Q: If I have a Heartbeat of Spring or a Reflecting Pool, and it copies the mana produced by a Hall of the Bandit Lord, or Boseiju, Who Shelters All, does the copied mana have the extra ability (adding haste or uncounterability) as well? –Ben

A: No, the extra effect is not included with the mana. The types of mana are only the five colors of mana and colorless. Extra effects are not a part of the type of mana produced. This includes negative effects, too—with Heartbeat, Mishra's Workshop would produce three-colorless-only-for-artifacts plus one regular colorless.

Q: I have two Floating-Dream Zuberas tokens in play because of Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker. Is there an order in which they are sacrificed or are they all sacrificed at the same time? If I play Wrath of God, do I get two cards for each one, or one for one, then two for the second? –Brad

A: Kiki-Jiki tokens will be sacrificed one at a time. Their “at end of turn” triggers will stack on top of each other. When the “at” trigger resolves, you'll sack one, and trigger a draw for one. After drawing, you'll resolve the other “at” trigger and cause a trigger to draw two. Total drawn: three.

For the Wrath version, you'll draw two for each. The zuberas die at the same time, and then their abilities start to resolve. Each one sees that two Zubera have already gone to the graveyard. Total draw: four.

Q: Suppose I control Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker and Academy Rector. Will a dying Rector token trigger, be removed from the game, and fetch me an enchantment from my library? --Jesse McE.

A: No, a Mirrored Rector will not exist long enough to fetch an enchantment. When the token is sacrificed, it does go to the graveyard, and the ability does trigger, but just before putting the trigger on the stack, state-based effects check, and the token-not-in-play ceases to exist [CR 420.3 420.5f]. Thus, when the trigger resolves you are unable to meet the “if you do” requirement of removing the Rector's corpse from the game.

Q: I remove a divinity counter from Myojin of Life's Web. In my hand I have an Eternal Witness. Is there a way to play not only the Witness, but also a creature that I bring from my graveyard to my hand with the Witness? --Eric P.

A: No. The Eternal Witness' triggered ability still needs to go onto the stack and resolve. In short, if the creature card isn't in your hand when you start resolving the Myojin's ability, you won't get to put it into play.

Horobi, Death's Wail
Q: How does Horobi, Death's Wail interact with the modular ability? I know the placement of the +1/+1 counters is optional, but is the targeting? --Tommy K.

A: Choosing a target for the ability is not optional even though putting counters onto something is. For example, let's say you opponent has oh… three Arcbound Ravagers. If you target one while Horobi is in play, when Horobi's trigger resolves, that Ravager will be sacrificed. Then that player will have to target one of his artifact creatures with the modular trigger [CR 410.4]. Once the target is chosen, Horobi triggers again, and the process continues. If the opponent had an Ornithopter or other non-modular artifact creature, they could stop the cycle of violence by targeting (and thus losing) the Ornithopter.

Q: When I resolve Cranial Extraction, could I use this opportunity to see what my opponent's library holds? For instance, if I want to know how may copies of a certain card are in there for Mindblaze? Is this legal? --Hagai R.

A: Yes, you search the library, so you see the contents of the library.

*Extra* In tournaments you are allowed to take notes while in a match, but you must make them quickly. Jot down initials and numbers, but don't take much time or you could invoke the ire of the judges.

Q: Does Konda's Banner pump the equipped creature? Does a creature share a type with itself? --Geoff F.

A: Yes, the equipped Legendary creature will get +1/+1 if it has a type and +1/+1 if it has a color. This bonus will be shared with all creatures with the appropriate type and/or color as applicable.

*Extra* Note that “Legendary” is a supertype, not a type, so being Legendary doesn't cause pumping. Also note that not all Legendary creatures have a creature type (check the unemployment roster). And not all Legendary creatures have a color (such as Karn, Silver Golem [Yeah, even though he's silver.]). Karn will still get +1/+1 for having a type (Golem), and Baron Sengir will get +1/+1 for having a color (black).

Q: I play Shatter targeting my opponent's Tatsumasa, the Dragon's Fang, and in response he pays 6 and makes a blue 5/5 Dragon Spirit, then I play Smother targeting the token.

Will my Shatter destroy the equipment when it returns to game? --Gustavo M.

A: No-- any time a card moves from one zone to another, the game treats it as a brand new object (the keyword “phasing” excepted). The freshly returned Dragon's Fang is not considered the same permanent even though the physical cardboard might be the same.

Q: If Tatsumasa, the Dragon's Fang is equipped, and I pay the cost to make it into a 5/5 Dragon Spirit, does the Dragon's Fang come back equipped to my creature? Does the Dragon's Fang come back if the token was removed from the game without hitting the graveyard (with AEther Snap perhaps)? --Chris D

A: A returning Dragon's Fang will not be equipped to anything [CR Glossary: Equipment].

If the Dragon Spirit token is not put into a graveyard (ie: it's bounced or removed from the game), the Dragon's Fang will not return to play.

Into the Wayback Machine

Q: I have Confusion in the Ranks in play and I play a Summoner's Egg while holding Phage the Untouchable. My opponent has a Shatter in hand. Can I stack the imprint and the Confusion to imprint Phage and not lose from the Shatter? –Nick

A: You control both cards, so you may stack both the triggers as you wish. If you stack “Imprint — When Summoner's Egg comes into play, you may…” and then stack the Confusion trigger on top of it (you stack your own triggers in any order [CR 410.3]), then you'll resolve the Confusion trigger, and then resolve the imprint trigger. This way, Phage doesn't get imprinted on the Egg until your opponent controls it, so you're not in any danger of losing.

Do note that your opponent will have the opportunity to Shatter the Egg before the imprint trigger resolves. He could even Shatter it before the Confusion trigger resolves, to stop the exchange from happening and keep the artifact you're trying to steal.

Synod Sanctum
Q: I have a Synod Sanctum in play, and I have removed some of my permanents from the game. My opponent tries to destroy the Sanctum, so I bounce it back to my hand. Can I replay the Sanctum, and then sacrifice it to return those permanents to play, or do they cease to exist once the Sanctum leaves play? --Theron M.

A: The cards would not be returned to play. Though they'd still exist as cards (not permanents [CR 214.1]), the new Synod Sanctum doesn't know anything about its previous life.

Q: Can a Shunt shunt a Counterspell onto itself? If you can, doesn't that make the target illegal because Shunt has already resolved? Have I found a way to counter a Last Word? -- B. R. C.

A: Itself? Depends on your pronoun reference. Ok, let's spell this one out: You can Shunt a Counterspell so it targets the Shunt. The Shunt then leaves the stack, and the game will counter the Counterspell for lack of target [CR 413.2a].

You cannot shunt a Counterspell so the Counterspell targets itself. Spells are not allowed to target themselves [CR Glossary: Target].

Yes, this means you can cause a Last Word to be countered. Last Word says that it can't be countered by spells or abilities. Counter for lack of target (often called “fizzle”) is a game rule that's doing the countering, and a game rule is neither a spell nor ability.

Q: Does March of the Machines kill artifact lands that are indestructible? If so can I make a Darksteel Colossus a 0/0 and make him go to the graveyard? --Malcolm H.

A: Yes and yes-ish (the Colossus will get shuffled in instead of put into the graveyard). Putting zero-or-less-toughness creatures into the graveyard is a state-based effect, not a “destroy” effect [CR 420.5b].

Q: When someone is trying to destroy my Clone of a Darksteel Colossus do I shuffle the Clone back into my library or does it die? --Tommy C.

A: A Cloned Darksteel Colossus would get shuffled back into your library. “Destroy” isn't a likely way to kill a Colossus, so let's just pretend some cruel person Edicted you.

Q: If I play Grab the Reins with entwine can I take my opponent's Avatar of Woe, tap it to destroy his our creature, and then sac it to the entwine and do 6 damage to other creature? –Sam

A: No, once Grab the Reins starts resolving you have to finish resolving it (taking a guy and tossing a guy) before you get priority to do anything else.

Q: Suppose my opponent has an Upwelling in play and we've both accumulated a ridiculous amount of mana. I have a Mindslaver in play. Can I activate it, targeting myself, and then on my next turn destroy his Upwelling, killing him but not me? --Nathan McC.

A: No. The rule avoiding mana burn only applies to a player “while another player controls his or her turn” [CR 507.4]. Since you're still controlling your turn, you'll still mana burn like normal.

Q: If a creature like Warbreak Trumpeter has a morphing ability that includes two X's and a mountain what do the two X's mean? –Judy

A: The means you have to choose an amount for X, then pay plus twice that X amount. In Warbreak Trumpeter's case, let's say you wanted three Goblin tokens. Then the X would be three, and the mana you'd have to spend is ( + + )… .

Q: If I have Dralnu's Crusade in play, along with Noxious Ghoul, would a Goblin that enters play trigger the Ghoul's ability, or just become a Zombie afterwards and not trigger the ability? –Nathan

A: The ability triggers. Continuous effects (such as Dralnu's Crusade) apply even as creatures come into play. Thus, the Goblin enters play as a “Creature – Goblin Zombie” that is black and gets +1/+1.

Volrath's Laboratory
Q: Volrath's Laboratory allows me to make tokens of the creature type of my choice. Since Island Fish Jasconius has the creature type "Island," I assume I can then make Island tokens If I cast Echoing Truth on one of these tokens, what happens to lands with the name "Island" that are in play? --Arlen S.

A: Actually, Island Fish Jasconius is a “Creature — Island-Fish”. The hyphen makes this a single creature type, which doesn't match either Island or Fish. So Islands will not be affected, but any other creatures named Island-Fish are toast.

Q: If I have a Goblin Bombardment and Spirit Mirror in play during my upkeep can I infinitely sacrifice a creature to the Bombardment and keep getting a creature from the Mirror since it is still out it play. --Frank G.

A: No, the current wording for the Mirror triggers “At the beginning of your upkeep”. Since your upkeep only begins once each turn, it can only make one Reflection per turn. (The card originally said “during your upkeep”, which makes it less clear… but it has always been designed to work this way).

Q: If I have a Samite Healer and my opponent attacks with a Serra Angel with Gratuitous Violence in play, how much damage do I take? Is it 4 x 2 = 8 then prevent 1 (take 7) or is it prevent 1 then 3 x 2 = 6? –Darren

A: It's your choice [CR 419.9a]. Since you're the player affected (you're about to get smashed), you decided which order to apply the replacement (GV) and the prevention (SH) to the event that's affecting you. If you apply the prevention first, then you double the remaining three into six. If you apply the doubling first, then you'll prevent one of the eight and take seven. The key with replacements and prevention is who controls the affected permanent or is the affected player—whose turn it is doesn't matter.

*Extra* If you were being attacked by a 1/1 instead, you block with the Samite Healer and then prevent one to the Healer. Because you control the Samite you'll make the choice about how to apply the replacement and prevention affecting it. You could prevent the one and then double zero into zero.

Feeling a Little Sick?

Getting pulled through the vacuous reaches of time and space is hard on most beings. Typically all they want to do is sit down and rest. Polar Kraken, Skyshroud Behemoth, and Leviathan are so tuckered out that they even take a nap. To help convey this particular syndrome, people often use the phrase “summoning sick”. But what exactly is summoning sickness? Have a seat in the waiting room, and Dr. John Carter will be with your shortly. [Cue ER theme song]

Let's start with the textbook definition of summoning sickness from the Comprehensive Rules Glossary:

Summoning Sickness (Informal)
The term “summoning sickness” is an informal term which describes a creature's inability to attack or to use activated abilities that include the tap symbol when it has come under a player's control since the beginning of that player's most recent turn. See rule 212.3d. See also Haste.

Summoning sickness is Magic's common cold. “Common cold” isn't a technical statement so much as an idea of what's going on with your runny nose and achy body. Likewise, saying something is “summoning sick” is a flavorful way of saying that you haven't controlled a given creature continuously since the start of your most recent turn and thereby the creature is unable to attack or to use abilities with the tap symbol.

Saproling Burst
Q: When I bring in tokens with Saproling Burst by removing a fade counter, can those creatures attack the turn they come into play? –Rob

Q: If you return creatures directly from your graveyard to play with a spell such as Patriarch's Bidding can those creatures attack and/or tap the turn they are put back into play? --Jon H.

A: No, the new creatures haven't been under your control continuously since you began your turn.

Q: What does “unaffected by summoning sickness” mean? A: Creatures with that wording such as the Mirage Talruum Minotaur predate the introduction of “haste”. The Sixth Edition Talruum Minotaur is functionally the same but has the haste keyword instead. Both wordings mean that the creature can be used to tap or attack regardless of how long a player has controlled it.

Symptom by symptom:

  • Summoning sickness applies to creatures—non-creatures can track if they have been under you control since the start of the turn, but summoning sickness doesn't apply unless they become creatures. This is why you can't attack with a Blinkmoth Nexus you just played; activating it is fine, but once it becomes animated, the sickness sets in, and you won't be able to attack with or tap it. If you controlled the Nexus since you started the turn, then animating it wouldn't cause any problems since it know you've controlled it continuously since the turn began.
  • Summoning sickness “wears off” when you start your turn—any creatures you control at that time will be ready to go.
  • If a creature leaves your control and comes back, it becomes sick again—this is why you'll see the word “continuously” when talking about controlling sick creatures.
  • Using abilities with the tap symbol and attacking are not allowed.
  • Using abilities with no tap symbol (such as the sacrifice ability on Arcbound Ravager) and blocking as perfectly fine.
  • An ability whose Oracle text says to tap a creature without the tap symbol itself works fine with sick and non-sick creatures. Azami, Lady of Scrolls does this with wizards, and Earthcraft does this with any creature.

There you have it all bandaged up. When people talk about things having summoning sickness, they're using a simple phrase to describe a series of complex interactions. Once you start a turn with a creature, it'll be feeling better and be ready to do your bidding.

Class dismissed.

--Carter

Latest Feature Articles

FEATURE

May 18, 2022

Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate Mechanics by, Jess Dunks

The beloved adventure of Dungeons & Dragons returns to Magic once more in Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate. This set visits one of D&D's most iconic settings, introduce...

Learn More

FEATURE

May 17, 2022

Collecting Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate by, Max McCall

Editor's Note: We wanted to provide a clarification that the card Faceless One does not come in the foil-etched or traditional foil treatments. Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gat...

Learn More

Articles

Articles

Feature Archive

Consult the archives for more articles!

See All