The Psychic Vortex Challenge

Posted in Feature on November 24, 2004

By Adrian Sullivan

Psychic Vortex
It's been nearly two months since the results of the Uyo Challenge, and once again I see the readers are fired up about trying to meet my challenge. I profiled Psychic Vortex two weeks ago, and I have to say that people were very enthusiastic about my look at the card. Psychic Vortex just stands out as one of those cards that really does inspire the imagination. I remember the first time that I looked at the card and tried to figure out what I could do to abuse the “cost” of the card. Judging from all of the creative deck submissions for the Challenge, it seems like it has done its job in inspiring you as well.

Unlike previous challenges, there was a great deal more diversity in the submissions. I did have quite a few people send in Donate decks, intending to give a Vortex to an unsuspecting opponent, often combined with Underworld Dreams or some other such trick. Unfortunately, an opponent isn't required to pay upkeep, so except in the case of those decks that instead centered on Eon Hub, none of those decks worked. Seismic Assault was another popular card, and one of the Seismic Assault submissions did get the nod this week. The criteria I've used to judge the decks remains the same since the beginning of Card Challenges way back with the Sundering Titan Challenge 37 weeks ago. They are:

  • Decks that focus on doing something and doing it well
  • Decks that have that little extra creativity or innovation
  • Speed as a tiebreaker – get your submission in sooner, you beat out a similar deck

Simple, really. There were a lot of great submissions this week, so it was harder than usual. Combine that with having to stay in bed all weekend from illness, and you had one very sad writer trying to find the best submissions. It could be said that those submissions that helped me feel better got a slightly stronger nod than others, and I also want to thank all of the people who mentioned enjoying my movie references – each e-mail really did make me feel a little better. With that said, let's check out the winning decks.

The Honorable Mention: Rat-tastic

This first submission isn't nearly as honed as a lot of the other submissions that aren't getting mentioned this week, but it made me laugh out loud when I saw it. That, combined with the creative use of a previous card I've covered in my column, Relentless Rats, really made me want to put a little spotlight on krizc's Legacy (formerly known as "Type 1.5") legal deck.

krizc writes:

I have a really crazy idea with Psychic Vortex. It's a silly B/g/u deck that revolves around Relentless Rats. Basically, the deck is mostly black Rat aggro until you can get out a Psychic Vortex/Aluren engine. You gradually end up drawing a fistful of rats each turn, and getting to play them all for free, which negates the penalty of having to sacrifice most of your lands. The deck plays out like any other relentless rats deck, but has that extra punch if the side-combo gets played. Naturalize is there just in case you have only the Vortex out, and if it's hurting you more than it's helping. The best part of this deck is that it can still win as a rat deck even if the Vortex is not in play.

Somehow, I imagine the Vortex helps, though. Here is the list:

The Honorable Mention: Rat-tastic

Download Arena Decklist
Creature (24)
24 Relentless Rats
Instant (4)
4 Naturalize
Enchantment (8)
4 Aluren 4 Psychic Vortex
60 Cards

I can see that the decklist could use a little bit of help. The biggest thing that could probably be improved is the mana base. Fellwar Stone or Talismans of some kind could really help improve the speed of the deck, and if you really want to add money to the deck, you could always add in actual dual lands. For less money, Gemstone Mine is always a great inclusion in a Vortex deck (so long as you don't use too many) – it's going to die anyway, so why not have good mana fixing in the meantime? I'm not sure if Naturalize is necessary at all – I think I'd rather just have the additional mana acceleration If you do include dual lands, Nature's Lore might be a really good idea, getting you both more mana and fixing your colors.

While certainly not the most potent of submissions, I really enjoyed the idea of using a powerful card like Psychic Vortex to simply power out a bunch of lowly rats.

Third Place: Pallinchron Bridge

Say congratulations to Christian Moeller-Holst from Denmark, for his impressive 3rd appearance in a challenge. Christian's deck is similar to the finalist's deck, but includes a card I've always enjoyed: Palinchron. With Palinchron being essentially free, there is something exciting about the possibility of drawing several cards and then dropping numerous Palinchrons on the next turn. Here is his list:

Third Place: Pallinchron Bridge

Download Arena Decklist

One of the fun things about the deck is that with Ensnaring Bridge your opponent may not be able to attack, but once you draw from the Vortex, your Palinchrons will be able to. The interaction between Null Brooch, Psychic Vortex, Manabond, and Ensnaring Bridge is just wonderful. Christian has a couple of useful things to say about his list:

You mentioned the Null Brooch in your article and I must admit that I really like it in this deck since it also works very well with Ensnaring Bridge. It is also very nice to have some way to counter spells, should your opponent have some way of dealing damage without attacking. Turbulent Dreams is another card that you mentioned in your article, and since it also works wonders with the Bridge, as well as hold off the enemy until you'll get the missing cards, I've chosen to include it as well. I don't think that Birds of Paradise needs much explanation, it's just a great card - it's that simple, and it helps me power out a lethal Fireball. The win conditions are Fireball and Palinchron, as I should have plenty of mana to kill the opoonent. The odd one-of is the Crucible of Worlds, but I figured that it would be sort of okay in this deck, though I'm not really sure just how good.

The deck includes Intuition as a useful tutor spell that can help finish any part off, and Intuition/Gaea's Blessing can also be used to keep an almost expired deck from being completely used up by a long game. One of the weaknesses of this deck is that it is pretty hard to get the deck going against someone with countermagic – should they keep the Vortex out of play, it could be very rough. Generally a deck like this is going to want to get out Null Brooch first, as potential protection for the Vortex. With that in mind, I would strongly consider dropping the Crucible in this deck for yet another Null Brooch.

Congratulations again to Christian for his third entry into the deck challenges. I hope if we're ever at a big event together that we get a chance to meet! I've really enjoyed your approach to a lot of cards.

Finalist: Another Bridge deck

Brendan Flaherty had another submission that was quite similar to Christian's deck, but fundamentally different in its final approach. Running a combination of Stormbind and Seismic Assault as his primary path, his fully three-color version may not have the “cool” factor of Palinchron and Fireball for the kill, but it is definitely far more deadly than Christian's deck. Like Christian, he includes the powerful Vortex/Brooch/Bridge suite. Here is his list:

Finalist: Another Bridge deck

Download Arena Decklist

One of the features I especially like in this deck is the use of Far Wanderings. You can expect that a deck like this will be able to achieve Threshold quite quickly and easily, so Far Wanderings is very likely to grab three lands and more than make up for the Psychic Vortex land drawback. Far Wanderings also makes splashing for Seismic Assault much, much easier. Brendan talks about this in his own discussion of this deck:

Psychic Vortex gets you cards, lots of cards. For the average deck, about a third of these cards will be Lands, and most of these will be discarded, but I figure why not throw them into the graveyard yourself and pick up a little bonus on the side? This brings us to one of my favorite cards, Seismic Assault. Certainly an elegant card. We're going to be in a bit of a tight spot here, what with our Land being eaten off of the board as well as straight from the hand, but since they're all going to the same place, and this place is the graveyard, this is the ideal place to add Far Wanderings. That'll keep the Vortex happy for a few turns so we can keep chucking Islands at our opponent. Speaking of the opponent, they're going to be doing stuff between our turns, which can potentially be very bad. We can shut them down pretty tightly, though, with a couple of well placed artifacts that capitalize on our handlessness, namely, Ensnaring Bridge and another convenient gem, Null Brooch. Stormbind can keep excess copies of our main enchantments and Bridges from being dead cards, and we'll pack a couple of Reminisces to keep the combo rolling, and/or act as a little back-up. A handful of Green Walls for early defense and/or mana acceleration, and that's the core of the deck.

Well said! About the only major change I would make to this deck is to get a few Lightning Bolts in there instead of Fiery Temper. If you're going to be playing a deck that is otherwise Legacy legal, you might as well play the real Bolt here rather than a card that acts as good as a Bolt when you are lucky enough to discard it. Great analysis, Brendan, and good work.

The Winner: Enchantress-Vortex

We go down to beautiful Brazil for our winner this week. Francisco Barciella's very fun Enchantress deck abuses Vortex in a bunch of very satisfying ways. Check out this list:

The Winner: Enchantress-Vortex

Download Arena Decklist

Argothian Enchantress
One of the truly powerful things about this deck is its great ability to draw cards. Between all of the Enchantresses and the Vortexes, it can definitely keep playing and playing cards. Auratog is a truly great inclusion in the deck, and I'm very impressed with how it interacts with the Vortex as well, stopping the Vortex from getting to be too finicky if it has outworn its welcome and also serving as a very fine finisher. Words of Wind can accomplish the same trick of killing an overwhelming Vortex. With so much card drawing, drawing all of your cards could be a real threat, but fortunately Abundance can be used to avoid this – its ability replaces the draw, so Abundance is effective insurance against this final decking. Francisco especially likes these two cards together:
Abundance and Vortex is serious fun, with so many cards you can find anything you want. If you want to, you can Abundance for all lands and play it all with Manabond, or return all your lands with the Words of Wind and play it. The deck is pretty funny to play. I hope you like it.

Well, I definitely do. Exploration is already a card that works wonders with a Psychic Vortex, and combining that with an Enchantress engine is a good idea. The one Manabond acts as a more narrow “fifth” Exploration, and your Manabond/Words of Wind combo is pretty funny and mean at the same time. It shouldn't take long at all for this to overwhelm nearly anyone.

What I would do to pump up the deck a little is to get some more mana and some more enchantments in there at the same time. The deck has enough card drawing and doesn't really need Pursuit of Knowledge. Also, Intuition just seems like it would take a lot of time given the way the rest of the deck is set up. I would replace these cards with 4 Fertile Ground and 1 Rancor. The Fertile Ground can really speed up the deck while giving you some cheaper enchantments. Rancor is really great with Auratog, and it can make that little enchantment muncher into a true-killer even if they have a decent blocker. Even before that point, Rancor and Auratog go really well together, especially if you have out some kind of Enchantress!

Wrapping Up

I hope you enjoyed this week's article and I want to thank everyone for all of the Challenge submissions I've received over the last two weeks. I'll be celebrating a birthday right around the time of my next column, so I hope I'll be in your thoughts as you read Scott Wills and MaRo's columns at the beginning of next week.

Have a great rest of the week!

Latest Feature Articles


August 15, 2022

Where to Find Dominaria United Previews by, Wizards of the Coast

It's time for Dominaria United previews! To help our readers and preview seekers, we've created this handy guide to preview season. August 18 at 9 a.m. PT is when everything begins with ...

Learn More


July 21, 2022

Lost Legends by, Blake Rasmussen

A long time ago—1994 to be exact—in a warehouse just far enough away, Legends were . . . lost. Case after case of the beloved Legends set sat on shelves waiting to be rediscovered, waitin...

Learn More



Feature Archive

Consult the archives for more articles!

See All