You've drawn "The Answer."
The back-and-forth that makes Magic fun is all about threats and answers. Ever since the days of Alpha, one player drops a Serra Angel and the other player has to suffer the righteous angelic beatings until he or she can find a Terror. And whether it's Alpha, Shadowmoor, or any Magic set in between for every threat in the game, there's an answer. For every Icy Manipulator, there's a Shatter. For every Calciform Pools, there's a Demolish.
But Magic's answers have a lot more depth than "Elvish Hexhunter your Bitterblossom." That's because Magic not only has threats and answers, it has answers to those answers (and then other answers to those answers). -1/-1 counters are the perfect example of these answers to answers, primarily through the vehicles of persist and wither.
Say you're playing green-blue against your friend's red-black deck in a Tenth Edition league. It's your second turn, and you have a Forest and an Island. Your friend has played tons of Shocks and Incinerates in previous games, and it has been almost impossible to make your turn-two creature survive. No matter what creature you have played on turn two, it has instantly died in a fire.
You think about all the green or blue creatures for one and two mana in Tenth Edition and there is nothing that survives Incinerate. No matter what threat you present, your friend's Incinerate seems to be the universal answer.
You've answered the answer.
Persist vs. Tenth Edition
In this bizarre "Tenth Edition Limited plus fourteen persist cards" format, persist would be so powerful and so hard to answer that it would threaten to get really annoying and cross the line to not playing well. After all, there would be very few ways to stop the persist creatures in that world, and it would get frustrating that there wouldn't be enough ways to get around having to kill your opponent's Kitchen Finks twice in a row.
Fortunately, persist didn't debut in Tenth Edition at all and is instead nestled in the dark realm of Shadowmoor. Why does persist have so much better game play in Shadowmoor Limited than it would in Tenth Edition Limited? In a word: answers.
Just as -1/-1 counters keep Shadowmoor creatures alive through persist, those counters also doom persist creatures to a painful, tortuous, true death through wither, Incremental Blight, Puncture Bolt, and many other hideous fates. Those -1/-1 counter effects provide powerful answers to persist that keep persist in a more interactive place, which is that sometimes your 5/2 persist trample Scuzzback Marauders powerfully trades with your opponent's 5/5 Crabapple Cohort AND 5/4 Roughshod Mentor... and sometimes your Scuzzback Marauders just get permanently killed by your opponent's two-mana Puncture Bolt.
Part of the beauty of Magic is that for every threat, there's an answer. And for every answer, there's a different answer. Incinerate answers Imperious Perfect. Safehold Elite answers Incinerate. Boggart-Ram Gang answers Safehold Elite.
And the answers don't stop there. Can you think of a totally, totally sick answer to Boggart Ram-Gang, also built into Shadowmoor? Dusk Urchins! If you play Dusk Urchins and block Boggart Ram-Gang with it, you kill the Ram-Gang and draw three extra cards. If you attack with your Dusk Urchins into an opponent's Boggart Ram-Gang and the opponent blocks, you kill the Ram-Gang and draw four extra cards.
So then is Dusk Urchins the ultimate answer? The top of the food chain? The unanswerable answer? Of course not. What's a great answer to Dusk Urchins? Good old Incinerate! And so the quest for the perfect answer returns to where it started. No single answer is the be-all and end-all. There's always another step down the path.
From Microcosm to Macrocosm
This phenomenon of answers to answers plays out on many levels. When you're playing with a casual Magic group Tuesday nights and Jeff starts beating everybody up in duels with his Tattermunge Maniac / Flame Javelin deck, then the next week you'll probably see people playing more protection from red creatures like Silver Knight. That week people get beat up a bit by Silver Knight, so the next week they start playing more Llanowar Sentinels and 2/3s. Then people see that and next week they play Serra Angels. Then next week people play Nekrataals to kill the Serra Angels.
That cycle provides a new puzzle to solve every week as you try to tweak your decks to work best against whatever decks you think your friends will be running. And that puzzle is part of the fun of deckbuilding.
The same phenomenon occurs in single matches of Shadowmoor Limited. Maybe you didn't start out maindecking Lockjaw Snapper, but in Game 1, you see your opponent is playing black-red with multiple Gravelgill Axesharks and multiple Scuzzback Marauders. You can sideboard in the answer, Lockjaw Snapper, to fight those persist creatures.
But if this keeps happening to you for a couple of weeks, you can change your deck around to find an answer to the answer of Kitchen Finks. Then the next time this situation happens, you untap on turn-three, play a Forest, play Tower Above on your Tattermunge Maniac, and attack with everything. Your spell forces the opposing Kitchen Finks to block your 6/5 trample wither Tattermunge Maniac, you deal 6 damage to the opponent and kill the Kitchen Finks, the Finks don't persist back into play, and you lose nothing. You've answered the answer to your answer.
Answers in Standard Tournaments Beyond -1/-1 Counters
In maindecks or sideboards, Damnation is a powerful weapon in Standard. Putting a Twilight Shepherd into play answers Damnation hard since the Twilight Shepherd persists back into play and brings your other Damnationed creatures back to your hand. But Twilight Shepherd isn't immune to being answered itself. Oblivion Ring answers Twilight Shepherd hard, removing it from the game without ever triggering persist.
Condemn, Oblivion Ring, and other white removal effects that remove creatures from the game or put them into their owner's library give white a nice role to play in a persist world: the color whose creature control is the best answer to persist. R&D definitely intended that as a nice angle for white to have in Constructed formats that include Shadowmoor.
One of the things that keeps Standard tournament Magic vibrant and fun is the fact that you can find answers to answers far beyond the interactions of -1/-1 counters. They're woven throughout all the mechanics in the format, and you can find them if you look.
Creature decks have found they are far more effective against Faeries when they back up a low curve of cheap, aggressive weenies with Squall Line, Cloudthresher, Sulfurous Blast, or Firespout than when they don't bother to play enough of those answers. And just as Sulfurous Blast can answer Kithkin and Merfolk rushes, Kithkin and Merfolk decks in turn have found that Burrenton Forge-Tender can be a very effective answer to the Sulfurous Blast. Players who have sought powerful answers to an opposing turn-one Ancestral Vision have found success by answering with turn-two Riftsweeper.
Much like the -1/-1 counters of wither provide the perfect answer to the -1/-1 counters of persist, everything in Magic can be answered by something else and each of those answers can in turn be answered by something else in a beautiful, never-ending, spiral fractal called the metagame. Which of those fractal paths you explore is up to you.
Last Week's Poll
|Should we have printed Gathan Raiders as is?|
I'm glad so many people agreed that we were right to print Gathan Raiders as is, even though it's a hellbent card you can play without any red mana. For those who voted "It's complicated," I definitely agree. It's always tough to navigate the maze of reasons for when you should break your own rules and when you shouldn't. Such cases often lead to lively multiverse discussions and ad hoc debates in the Pit.
[The survey originally included in this article has been removed.]