Masters Edition III and Masters Edition IV are two of the more interesting projects I've ever worked on during my time at Wizards. Although I wrote preview articles for both sets, I have wanted for a while to write a crunchy development column about the Masters development process. This is that article.
When Magic Online was released, the most recent blocks were Invasion and Odyssey. Every paper set since Invasion, then, was released online. Later, we released Mirage online, and began moving forward from there. We are now all the way up to Urza's Legacy. We have not, however, released online any paper sets that came before Mirage. What gives?
Let's talk for a moment about one of the realities of Magic Online. In paper Magic, many players buy packs and open them for cards. The Magic Online audience, however, prefers to get cards by playing Limited. That's not a huge surprise, as Magic Online is the perfect venue for drafting whenever you want and over and over again if desired. However, this puts some restrictions on what kind of sets we can release online.
Theoretically, we could have just released The Dark online. However, that would have been a poor idea. It's likely that most of you have never attempted to draft The Dark. I have. It was horrible. I can't blame the designers and developers of The Dark for this, as Booster Draft didn't exist as a popular format then, but it was really awful. I would not wish it on anyone. People I knew who tried drafting other pre-Mirage sets reported similar experiences.
At the time, I didn't bother to investigate why these drafts didn't work. Working on the Masters sets several years later showed me what was actually going on.
- The Creatures in Old Sets All Suck
Modern Limited games all revolve around creature combat. That requires creatures in high enough power and quantity at low rarities that games play out normally. This was obviously not a concern to the people behind pre-Mirage sets; for example, in Legends, the only mono-red common creatures are Kobolds, Walls, and Blazing Effigy. This is not a recipe for fun drafting. Even when there were enough creatures, though, they were much weaker than we make creatures now.
- There Aren't Any Instants
I said just above that creature combat is one of the most important pieces of modern Limited. One of the keys to creature combat being fun is not knowing exactly how a given creature combat will go, and the key to surprises during combat is instants. We include tons of cards that can screw up a combat step so that surprises can happen, and we try to spread those cards around all the colors. For example, Magic 2011 contains
- White and Green Are Terrible
In modern sets, white and green tend to get the most strength from their creatures, and have somewhat weaker spells to compensate for that and keep colors balanced in power. As I already noted, though, creatures in old sets were uniformly less powerful, so the green and white creatures didn't pick up the slack. This meant that green and white were pretty much just worse. You'll also note that
- The Rares Are Not Good Enough in Limited
Rares in Limited do two very important jobs. One of those jobs is giving players direction. On a basic level, when you open up a
However, it encourages you to play tons of creatures in your deck, and starting with an
Although pre-Mirage sets are full of rares with unique and interesting effects, many of those cards are so goofy that they don't fit into an average Limited deck. That means that there aren't enough rares in decks to give the variety of experience that we've found that Magic players like.
As you can see, there are all kinds of problems with drafting those sets. Happily, Erik and I were able to compensate for them in Masters Edition IV. Here's how we did it.
I said above that the creatures in old sets were quite bad, and it's true. Thankfully, that's not true about the Portal sets, which saved us here. Those sets are full of cards like Ironhoof Ox, Alaborn Musketeer, Cloud Spirit, Goblin Firestarter, and Foul Spirit that are the bread and butter of modern Limited. Cards like that can only do so much to provide character and uniqueness to a format, of course, but that's what we used the cards from Limited Edition Beta, Arabian Nights, and Antiquities for. We were missing the simple cards, and that was exactly what Portal had to offer.
Using Portal to fill in the common creature gaps often does some strange things to the creative feel of the set. For example, Alaborn Musketeer's reach ability, quite strange for a white card these days, is justified by the enormous gun that he is holding. Masters Edition III was even more jarring, as heroic fantasy portraits like those on
I sometimes wonder what the designers and developers of the Portal sets would think if they saw a Southern Elephant being regenerated by an Elephant Graveyard or a
In contrast to the last problem, the Portal sets offer very little help here, as they were specifically designed to not have instants. We have since retrofitted several cards from the Portal sets with the instant type, as they actually functioned as such, but that only gave us a few cards in False Summoning and Just Fate.
For the rest of the instants, we had to look elsewhere. As it turns out, there were still instants to be found that we hadn't used in Masters Editions I, II, and III. Crumble, Divine Offering, and Terror are all strong instant removal spells that rival the best spells in modern sets. Gravebind, Sandstorm, Just Fate, Howl From Beyond, and
In the end, I feel that there are more than enough instants in the set for it to be fun to play. I would have liked to find even more so that some could be uncommon, meaning that they would show up less often and not be as correct to play around, but there simply weren't any more cards to include. As is, everything works just fine.
- Green and White
The problem with making white and green strong enough was the hardest of the four problems to solve. In Masters Edition IV, white has a bad Pacifism in Serra Bestiary and one of the strongest commons of the set in Divine Offering, which is a filthy card when Obsianus Golems and Clay Statues are running around. White also has an aggressive bent, supported by the common Righteous Charge, which is a fine way to put away a game when you have lots of creatures on the table.
Green was more challenging. Crumble and Scavenger Folk are both strong removal cards, which helps. Citanul Druid and Argothian Pixies are also strong against artifacts. Ironhoof Ox, Southern Elephant, and War Mammoth are some of the more efficient big creatures in the format. However, if an opponent of a green player is low on artifacts, things can get a little rough. I would, however, encourage green players to look out for Elephant Graveyard, which can make those War Mammoths and Southern Elephants much more intimidating.
Although finding exciting Constructed rares was no problem at all for Masters Edition IV, finding rares that mattered in Limited was harder. This was especially true due to cards like In the Eye of Chaos, Leeches, and Naked Singularity, that had to get into Magic Online somehow but were obviously unplayable in Limited. Those were blanks every time we opened them, and that's not a recipe for excitement.
We had to reach deep into the bucket for cards that would matter in Limited. Once again, the Portal sets were our saviors. Every time I found a simple but huge card like Cloud Dragon, Dread Reaper, or Thunder Dragon, I put it in, and over time the density of potentially game-ending rares got high enough. Although Deathcoil Wurm and Minion of Tevesh Szat aren't the cards that make you excited about playing Legacy or Classic, I think you'll still be glad when you open them.
The drive to put in Limited game-ending cards sometimes caused us to have two cards that feel very similar; for example, Overwhelming Forces and Rain of Daggers are both big and dumb cards that can put a game away. We would avoid this in a paper set, but we couldn't make new cards here. Even so, these two cards push you in different directions. Overwhelming Forces points you toward a control deck with lots of mana that stalls until you cast it, while Rain of Daggers' life loss encourages you to lean a little more aggressively. This kind of subtle difference exists in many pairs of similar Masters Edition IV, and drafters would do well to adjust for them.
Erik and I had a ton of fun working on Masters Edition III and Masters Edition IV. Masters Edition IV release events started two days ago, so there's still plenty of time to go and play. Next week, though, attention turns back to the broader as we begin Mirrodin Besieged previews. I hope you've enjoyed this little side trip, and I'll see you next Friday.
- Last Week's Poll
|Have you played Limited with Masters Edition, Masters Edition II, or Masters Edition III?|
|Yes, with all.||312||6.6%|
|Yes, with some.||437||9.2%|
- This Week's Poll