Once it became obvious that Onslaught was going to be the tribal block, some people in R&D made an impassioned plea for us to “bleed” creature types outside of their normal colors. This was back when the theme was just being designed and everyone knew that there was a limit to the number of races that we could make “matter.” If each color had a race of small things and a race of big things and some colors had a race of fliers and then white had both attack-oriented guys and defense-oriented guys (etc.) then that was more races than we could possibly support.
One way to address this problem would be to have races spill over into more than one color. That way the Goblin player, for example, could choose to play not just with red cards, but also with, say, blue cards. If Goblins bled into blue then suddenly there would be twice as many goblin cards and we wouldn’t need as many different races (since blue ground weenies could be Goblins). In addition, this would give Goblin theme decks a whole new dimension for deckbuilders to explore. Instead of always being mono-red, this new generation of Goblin decks could be two colors (or maybe even more). Because Onslaught wanted to take tribal decks to the new level, it needed to do something new with them. Besides, wouldn’t a blue Goblin be really cool?
The responses to these various arguments were many and loud. Sure, a blue Goblin would be new and weird and different and cool, but so would a green Counterspell and we all know that would be a bad idea. The colors are defined as much by what they can’t do as they are by what they can. Magic’s five-color structure requires us to give weaknesses to every color or else everyone would just play whichever color could do everything the best. According to this line of thought, we should leave Goblins in just red in order to keep red more special, and also in order to keep Goblins more special. If we did stuff (like blue Goblins) just because it hasn’t been done before then we’d just be giving in to the dark side; after doing that for a while there wouldn’t be any flavor or identity left for any of the colors, and the game would probably die.
So maybe not a blue Goblin, they countered, but we could still bleed races into colors where they make sense. Black Goblins, for example, seem perfectly reasonable from a flavor point of view. Tolkein’s goblins seem very black and a lot of Magic’s fantasy flavor is descended from our lord J.R.R.
Everyone agreed that it made sense to have races that were in more than one color, and that’s part of how we narrowed things down to just eight tribes. Birds are in blue and white, Clerics are in black and white, Beasts are in red and green (and a smattering elsewhere), and Wizards are mostly blue with a few scattered around elsewhere.
Some still felt that this wasn’t enough – they thought every tribe (or at least most tribes) should have multiple colors to choose from, that way when you went to build your theme deck you had a lot more options. The problem with this reasoning, we countered, was that it felt too much like gold cards. Gold cards are great, and we all love them, but just because I like vanilla ice cream doesn’t mean I want it for every meal of every day. Mechanics ebb and flow from block to block in Magic and the fact that things constantly change gives the game a lot of staying power. Besides, the rest of us didn’t think we needed to turn tribal into a multicolor mechanic in order to give deckbuilders enough options to enjoy themselves.
You can tell from Onslaught which side won this debate. However, the losing side still had a pretty good point about how Goblins made sense in black from a flavor point of view. Several of us in R&D were really disappointed that we had missed our opportunity to do a black-red Goblin Zombie in Invasion. At the time, the creative team argued that we had to do Shivan Zombie as a Barbarian Zombie because our cycle of 2/2’s required us to use the same red type on both that card and Yavimaya Barbarian. Since you couldn’t have a Goblin Elf, they argued, that meant the red type had to be Barbarian (not Goblin). I’m still not sure why you couldn’t have a Goblin Elf …. I mean, if the Elf was drunk who knows what might happen? It’s high time for Magic’s first inter-racial kiss! (Come to think of it, there is a Merfolk Elf…) Anyway, it’s probably a good thing that I’m not in charge of creative decisions like that, but it was still disappointing that we couldn’t have a Goblin Zombie and that’s the main reason Dralnu's Crusade was designed and put into Planeshift.
Flash-forward to Onslaught and we figured it would indeed be cool to give Goblin players a couple of cards that could tempt them into playing black-red. Festering Goblin and Cabal Slaver were the result and I think they were a nice compromise for a fairly contentious issue.
Last week’s poll:
|What color is your favorite card?|
Wow, a reasonably even spread… that’s pretty cool.Randy may be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org.