Playtesting the Very First Cards

Posted in Latest Developments on April 7, 2006

By Aaron Forsythe

Next week begins the official previews for Dissension, the latest and greatest Magic: The Gathering set. In my article that week—and for the next several weeks, I'm sure—I'll be talking about that set's cards and the development (and occasionally design) decisions that went into their creation.

But before heading off on that final leg of our Ravnica journey, I thought it would be a good idea to take a detour far, far back into Magic's past and talk with someone that was doing a job similar to my own over a dozen years ago.

Back in the early 1990's, before Magic cards were ever found in booster packs, Charlie Catino was one of the myriad playtesters from the University of Pennsylvania that Richard Garfield tagged to help get the Alpha card set (and game rules) ready for public consumption. In the years since, Charlie parlayed his association with Magic into a job as a full-time playtester here at Wizards, then matured into a proper designer and developer. From there he went to work on other Wizards TCGs like Netrunner and Vampire, did a stint as the head of Organized Play, and then later returned to R&D. He is currently the R&D Director of Japanese TCGs, and spends most of his time managing various Duel Masters teams and projects, although he still dabbles in Magic time and again, and was doing development as recently as the Mirrodin block.

I sat down with Charlie and asked him about the ins and out of testing that historic first few hundred cards…

“I was just a playtester,” he warned me. “I wasn't involved in many decisions; I just played the cards and reported my findings.” Actually, that's not so different from how I and other neophytes around R&D begin our training as developers nowadays: play a lot, talk about what's happening, and let the more experienced people fix the problems.

“Richard just wanted us to show him what could be done with Magic,” he continued, “but the cardpool was very limited.” Testing then, it turns out, was not at all like the constructed testing we do now, where we assume competitive players will obtain the maximum allowable copies of any given card. No, instead Charlie and the gang were playing something akin to an unrefined sealed deck league, with small numbers of cards available. “We basically printed about 20 common sheets [a sheet is approximately one of each card], seven uncommon sheets, and two rare sheets and divided them up among our group evenly. So even if you count the cards the guys had that were testing before us, there were only about five Black Lotuses available total.”

And if you wanted access to any of those cards, you had to go out of your way to trade for them. “One of the main decks I made at the beginning was black-white with Pestilence and protection from black creatures. From there I wanted to try something that used a lot of black mana for big Pestilences and Drain Lifes, so I tried getting a lot of Dark Rituals. Rituals #2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 weren't hard to get, but then people started getting nervous—'Charlie is trying to get all the Dark Rituals! Don't trade them!'—so numbers 9, 10, 11, and 12 were a lot harder to acquire. And I couldn't get any more after that.”

What Richard was looking for was an understanding of how enjoyable the game would be to play—the social experience was as important as the deckbuilding and the playing. “He didn't think people would spend hundreds of dollars on Magic,” explained Charlie, “but if they did spend more, hey, that's great—we'll fix whatever's broken.”

That comment led me to ask Charlie if they realized the “power” cards of the set were so far above the average card from their play experience. “We caught the power cards in time to give plenty of feedback to Richard,” he said, specifically calling out the Moxes, Time Walk and Ancestral Recall. “Again, no one could make a deck with all Moxes—or even all dual lands—because there just weren't that many of them. So we never ran into really degenerate situations.”

Was Charlie in a position to suggest costs or abilities for cards? “No, the first playtest group [Skaff Elias, Jim Lin, Chris Page, and Dave Pettey] did most of that—the costs were settled on. Richard was a great designer, sure, but he was also a great developer. He just wanted to make sure there were plenty of combos, and that we could understand the rules interactions. There weren't rulings for a lot of the stuff that could happen.

“I remember when [fellow playtester] Barry [Reich] played Unsummon on one of his creatures that was about to die, and we said, 'You can't do that! Richard didn't want it to work that way.' So Barry explained what he did to Richard and why he thought it was cool and that it should work that way, and Richard said sure. So there was a little bit of 'system development' going on.

“We played for ante a lot; my favorite deck for that was a bunch of common weenies like Merfolk of the Pearl Trident and Scryb Sprites, some Counterspells, and a couple Ancestrals. If you beat me all you'd win was usually some little 1/1. Bill [Rose] and I and the rest of the guys in Philly didn't really like ante, so we stopped playing that way, and didn't really ever try stuff like Demonic Attorney and Contract from Below.” Too bad they couldn't convince Richard to abandon that portion of the game—I still remember getting Demonic Attorney as one of the rares in the first starter deck I ever opened!

I asked Charlie if there were any cards he remembered being changed as a result of their testing. Library of Leng leapt to mind. “It originally let you set aside ten cards from your collection in a pile and draw from them. So one of the testers had a deck that used a bunch of Time Walks and counters and Swords to Plowshares to control the game, then would play the Library and go get a bunch of Serra Angels and Mahamoti Djinns to win the game with.”

One card that didn't change, though, was Chaos Orb, “even though we all hated it,” laughed Charlie. “And the players in the real world pretty much hated that thing too.”

Eventually the playtesters discovered the art of “proxying” their own fake cards, and the decks quickly became mathematical exercises. What wins faster, all Black Lotuses and Channels and Fireballs, or Time Walks and Ancestral Recalls? “Richard was aware all this stuff could be done ahead of time, but again, he figured if people were spending enough to be able to do that stuff, that was a good problem to have.”

When Magic was released, some of the playtesters moved with Richard to Washington, but Charlie, Bill Rose, and others stayed at Penn. There they began putting together the set that would later become Mirage on their own time. As the game grew, more positions in the company opened and Charlie was recommended by his old pals in 1994. As part of his job interview process, Charlie was told to play in a Magic tournament in Philadelphia using a deck he designed to maximize the effect of Balance, a card most players hadn't quite figured out yet. Charlie was skeptical of the idea, saying, “I'd been playing Magic longer than all these people, and I didn't think it would be fair to go in and crush them. But they wanted me to do it.” His first round opponent was just the kind of guy Charlie didn't want to sit across from—a newcomer with a 97-card deck containing everything but the kitchen sink. “Game one went like this—I Strip Mine his first land and he never plays anything else. Game two, I Strip Mine his first two lands and he never plays anything else. Turns out he had only twelve lands in 97 cards.”

Charlie would go on to finish second in the event, losing in the finals to Red Elemental Blasts, Serendib Efreets, and a bit of bad luck. But his performance impressed the folks “back at the office,” who gave him the job, making that the first and last Magic event he ever participated in.

Charlie was a great addition to Wizards R&D—the first set he worked on may have been Homelands, but the first development team he lead was the well-received Alliances. “I'd like to think I came a long way since my first week of playtesting with Richard when I told him that Circles of Protection were 'broken.'”

Charlie may have been off the mark there, but he's done a lot of great things for Magic and other games since, and enjoys a perspective on the TCG category that few others in the world can lay claim to.

Fun Fact: Charlie's name may seem familiar to those of you that have scanned Magic credits in the past—but not too familiar. Starting with the inadvertent typo of “Cateeno” in the game's first rulebooks, Charlie's name has been intentionally misspelled in every product he's work on since as a kind of running gag. Other spellings of Catino include “Cantripino,” “Cantini,” “Cantina,” and “Catman.”

Last Week's Poll:

What is your favorite Orzhov card?
Ghost Council of Orzhova 2314 20.1%
Debtors' Knell 1335 11.6%
Crime/Punishment 1249 10.8%
Angel of Despair 1184 10.3%
Pillory of the Sleepless 934 8.1%
Teysa, Orzhov Scion 682 5.9%
Blind Hunter 518 4.5%
Godless Shrine 417 3.6%
Souls of the Faultless 406 3.5%
Mourning Thrull 321 2.8%
Shadow Lance 316 2.7%
Castigate 259 2.2%
Orzhov Guildmage 220 1.9%
Shrieking Grotesque 191 1.7%
Agent of Masks 187 1.6%
Orzhov Pontiff 156 1.4%
Cry of Contrition 140 1.2%
Seize the Soul 125 1.1%
Belfry Spirit 87 0.8%
Culling Sun 76 0.7%
Orzhova, the Church of Deals 75 0.7%
Graven Dominator 72 0.6%
Conjurer's Ban 62 0.5%
Orzhov Euthanist 43 0.4%
Benediction of Moons 33 0.3%
Moratorium Stone 32 0.3%
Orzhov Basilica 27 0.2%
Revenant Patriarch 19 0.2%
Orzhov Signet 17 0.1%
Ostiary Thrull 11 0.1%
Absolver Thrull 9 0.1%
Exhumer Thrull 7 0.1%
Total 11524 100.0%

I left Mortify off the list on purpose… that would have been too easy a choice.

Latest Latest Developments Articles


June 9, 2017

Changes by, Sam Stoddard

Hello and welcome to another edition of Latest Developments! Today I'm going to talk about several kinds of changes within R&D and how we deal with those. Card Changes From the day ...

Learn More

Latest Developments

June 2, 2017

Things I've Learned by, Sam Stoddard

Hello, and welcome to another edition of Latest Developments! This week is the five-year anniversary of me joining Wizards of the Coast as a contractor on the development team. My officia...

Learn More



Latest Developments Archive

Consult the archives for more articles!

See All