Something Not In Unhinged

Posted in Latest Developments on November 12, 2004

By Aaron Forsythe

Before We Start…

The results of the new name for the “Type 1.5” format is in, and the winner is Legacy. Get used to seeing it!

Here are the results:

What should be the new name of Type 1.5?
Legacy 2963 25.5%
Traditional 2708 23.3%
Renaissance 1858 16.0%
Heritage 1207 10.4%
Throwback 655 5.6%
Ageless 572 4.9%
Comprehensive 558 4.8%
Timeless 544 4.7%
Mosaic 368 3.2%
Enduring 187 1.6%
Total 11620 100.0%

I got a lot of email about why certain options were not listed in the poll, so I want to clear that stuff up.

  • Open and Classic are names of formats on Magic Online, and these formats are structured differently than 1.5, so these names are off limits.
  • Eternal and Composite are names of ratings categories that the DCI uses, and for that reason these names are off limits as well.
  • Vintage Restricted was mentioned a lot, but it makes no sense for the format with a Restricted List to be called “Vintage,” and the format without one to be called “Vintage Restricted.”
  • Words with negative connotations, either subtle or overt, like Confined and Antiquated were not given serious consideration by the selection committee.
  • Words that no one would know were generally not given consideration, even if they would have made sense from a strict definition standpoint, like Amaranthine.
  • Finally, while we all had a good laugh over goofy names like Overextended and Hyper-Extended, we would like the format to be taken seriously.

That left us with what you saw in the poll last week. I do think the winner is fitting, and we'll all be comfortable with it in no time.

The Windup

If you read my article “A-Proxy-Mation” about the methods of making playtest cards here in R&D, you'll recall that we have access to Magic cards with normal backs and plain white fronts on which we can write whatever we want.

I'm a visual-minded person, so I like my hand-written proxies to be legible across the table and to have some clear indicator of color. Almost two years ago, back when Mirrodin and Darksteel were in development and I was still working as Content Manager for this website, I bought a sweet 12-pack of various colored Sharpie markers at Target. The cool part was that there was a bonus silver Sharpie thrown in for free!

Simple things amuse me, and I was very happy to own all these Sharpies. I was carrying around a Future Future League deck in my bag at the time (a bad Onslaught-Mirrodin red-green land destruction deck), and when I got home that night, I took out the cards and started doodling on them with my new pens. Here are three examples of my handiwork:

I had no motives for making the cards look that way, just some spare time and some cool pens. I took the deck back to work the next day and played it a few times in R&D. The deck ended up doing poorly, but what did strike me was how nice my hand-drawn cards looked on the table.

The Pitch


squirrel token
During this time, Mark Rosewater was starting up the design of Unhinged in earnest, and was asking anyone and everyone for wacky ideas for the set. I asked if the set was going to have token cards in it (like Unglued's Sheep token, for example), but Mark said no, tokens were under the jurisdiction of the Magic Player Rewards program.

I pulled out my little drawings and showed them to him. “Maybe we should do something like this,” I said. “Cards with all art and no text box.” Both he and Randy Buehler liked the idea and put it on their list of stuff to work into the set.

The cards sounded good in theory. There would be five of them--one per color--and they'd be black bordered so as to be legal in tournament play. Like the token cards and the basic lands did for Unglued, these cards would give even serious tournament players a reason to be intrigued by Unhinged. Because very little relevant game information would be on the cards, we'd stick to instants and sorceries so that these textless cards weren't hanging out in play. The problem was finding the right five cards.

Because these cards would have nothing on them that would indicate how they played--not even a card type--the spells chosen had to be very well known by Magic players of every skill level. For red, Shock seemed like a great choice. Giant Growth was the most well known green spell, but it was a little lackluster since it rarely shows up in competitive decks. After that, pickings got thin. We could choose cards that people knew, or cards that were in Standard at the time, but the overlap wasn't great. And white proved to be particularly problematic. The most well known white spells tend to be rare (like Wrath of God) or not really white any more (like Disenchant), and we weren't happy doing either. And yes, Swords to Plowshares did come up as an option. But really, what percentage of current players know what Swords to Plowshares does without being able to read it? The number is lower than you'd think.

Because Unhinged was meant for the entire Magic audience, both new and enfranchised, the idea of textless spells was a poor fit because they couldn't serve both audiences well. Cards that new players knew well enough to not need to read would not be very exciting as promos for older players. And cards that older players liked would be baffling to new players without words. So sadly, the idea was scrapped.

Dusting Them Off

Months later, Randy Buehler was at a tournament team meeting when people from organized play started prodding him for ideas for new token cards to give away for Player Rewards. Randy knew that the quality of token creatures had gone down since the days of Odyssey and Onslaught--how compelling is a Pentavite card, really?--and told the team that there just weren't that many good token-makers in Champions of Kamigawa. But--aha!--he had a solution. What if, instead of token cards, Player Rewards gave away textless spells? We had the idea in our back pockets with no other good place to use it, and Player Rewards seemed like the perfect fit.

Because players that receive cards as part of Player Rewards have, by default, played in at least five tournaments recently, the barrier of knowing what textless spells did would be lessened, especially if the cards chosen were from the current Standard environment. While not every Magic player knows what Oxidize does by heart, anyone that has played Standard recently sure does.

They Exist

Organized Play liked the idea and went ahead with it. Five cards were chosen, and Magic art director Jeremy Cranford commissioned them to be done in a style that fits with Champions of Kamigawa, even though the cards themselves may be from other sets. Many of you have received the Terror in the mail (or saw them in this popular Magic Arcana), so here's a look at another from the series, Oxidize:

If you play one of these against an opponent that doesn't know the card, call over a judge or find a copy of the regular version. Note that the problem of unreadable cards is an old one--foreign cards have been tournament-legal forever, and often you can't even make out the name on those! Somehow we all survive, however, and I imagine these textless spells are going to go over big. Assuming they do, we'll be making new ones every year.

We'll keep making token cards as well, and mixing those in with the Player Rewards cards when they're relevant. There's a Kamigawa Spirit token floating around that works with Honden of Life's Web, Dripping-Tongue Zubera, and Forbidden Orchard.

The irony of Player Rewards taking the tokens from Unhinged and then taking the thing that was meant to replace the tokens from Unhinged is not lost on me. Luckily, Unhinged still has its own beautiful basic lands that are legal in sanctioned play.

This Week's Poll:

A quick change of the subject. The recent Extended Pro Tour in Columbus was an amazing thing to watch from my perspective, as the format was the most diverse I'd ever seen in Constructed. Everything was there… madness, reanimator, affinity, burn… heck, this is the first time multiple copies of UNHPlains have showed up in a Top 8 in at least the last four Extended PTs! It feels like any deck can win, giving rogue deckbuilders hope, but the openness of the format means that it is awfully hard to prepare fully for everything you'll see.

The question is:

Latest Latest Developments Articles


June 9, 2017

Changes by, Sam Stoddard

Hello and welcome to another edition of Latest Developments! Today I'm going to talk about several kinds of changes within R&D and how we deal with those. Card Changes From the day ...

Learn More

Latest Developments

June 2, 2017

Things I've Learned by, Sam Stoddard

Hello, and welcome to another edition of Latest Developments! This week is the five-year anniversary of me joining Wizards of the Coast as a contractor on the development team. My officia...

Learn More



Latest Developments Archive

Consult the archives for more articles!

See All