Ahoy there, matey! Once again you’ve joined our cast here at MagicTheGathering.com. This week I’m looking at the history of cards with an alternate play cost. These are the spells which can be played by ways and means other than the mana cost printed in their upper right hand corner. So without further ado, let’s cast off to see which spells are out there!
Our beginning point on this voyage isn’t a card with an alternate play cost at all—there’s no way for Nether Shadow to be played from your hand to the table on its own aside from adding two black mana to your mana pool and putting him gingerly onto the table. It’s the ability of this undead spirit to come back into play under certain conditions—for no mana—which looks similar to APC’s (alternate play cards). Surely the mechanic on this card inspired the set of five cards to follow a few brief sets down the road in Alliances.
I’LL TAKE ONE
Alliances was the first Magic expansion set to be designed expressly as a part of a block. It used the mechanics from Ice Age such as snow-covered lands and cumulative upkeep. While Storm Elemental and Splintering Wind are all but forgotten by modern-day players, the new mechanic that debuted in Alliances revolutionized the game. The concept was ingeniously simple: instead of paying the mana costs of this cycle of five and six mana cost cards, a player could remove a card of a similar color from the game, possibly lose a life, and play the card for free (as far as mana was concerned).
These initial five were a huge success. Scars of the Veteran, Bounty of the Hunt, Pyrokinesis, Contagion, and Force of Will all saw considerable play, with the last becoming a staple in nearly every format in which it appeared. Suddenly each color could perform while tapped out of mana: white could save itself/its creatures, green could give size bonuses, red and black could kill creatures, and blue could play Counterspell from a particularly vulnerable board position. It was, and still is, this last card which has proved the most troublesome over the years. We’ll explore why a little later in the article, but just keep in mind for now that while all of these five were good, Force of Will might have been a little TOO good.
HERE AND THERE
These cards showed up sporadically over the course of the next few blocks. Visions produced Fireblast, which immediately became a fixture in fast red decks. Weatherlight gave black mages Spinning Darkness, the first alternate play card which used the graveyard as a resource. Then came Stronghold.
Dream Halls isn’t an alternate play card in and of itself, but it turns every spell in your hand into a neo-Alliances pitch card. The mechanic finally blew wide open over the course of the next year, with combo decks feature Mana Vault, Dream Halls and card drawing engines dominating the post Tolarian Academy/Memory Jar tournament scene. Dream Halls decks became all the rage, and drew the banning of the namesake card of the deck. This came just in time for the mass-reintroduction of this mechanic in the Masques Block.
EVERYBODY JUST WANTS TO BE FREE
Mercadian Masques used alternate play cost as one of the block mechanics, and explored it more fully than it had been in the past. Each color had a standard alternate cost, along with two cycles of hoser cards and a pitch-card cycle similar to the Alliances cycle. Black sacrificed creatures (Dark Triumph, Delraich, Mind Swords) or paid life (Rouse, Snuff Out). Green gave life to the opponent (Invigorate, Reverent Silence, Skyshroud Cutter) or revealed its hand (Land Grant). Red sacrificed lands (Crash, Downhill Charge, Mogg Alarm, Pulverize, Thunderclap). White tapped its own creatures (Angelic Favor, Lashknife, Orim's Cure, Ramosian Rally, Sivvi's Valor). Blue returned lands to its hand (Daze, Ensnare, Gush, Thwart, Tidal Bore).
The two color hose cycles (one in Masques and one in Nemesis) finally introduced cards which could be played for free… under the right circumstances. The Legate cycle from Masques were creatures which were free if you controlled the correct land and your opponent controlled an opposing one. A similar cycle hosed the opposite way along the color wheel, except this time with spells.
A final cycle of APC cards came in Prophecy, the last set of the Masques block. This time around, each color could pitch a land appropriate to the card’s color (or in blue’s case with Foil, a island plus another card) in order to avoid paying mana for a spell.
LOTS OF PEOPLE GOTS THE BLUES
Unfortunately, alternate play cost cards went a long way towards making blue a bit overpowered. Since blue’s main strategy is reactive, part of the inherent weakness of the color is that when blue taps out, it’s powerless to stop whatever the opponent throws out on the table. Force of Will changed the way blue was played—previously a board of tapped Islands meant you could go for it. Now it meant that your game breaking play might be stopped at the cost of a card in hand and a single life.
As if Force of Will didn’t change the dynamic of the entire color enough, Masques block added FOUR more "free" counterspells to blue’s repertoire. Thwart, Misdirection, Daze, and Foil all worked in the same way as Force of Will, but with two (Daze/Thwart) coming at the cost of tempo instead of life and a card. Of these, Misdirection (the closest to Force of Will in regular mana cost and alternate play cost) proved the most troublesome for non-blue players. Red began getting "uncounterable" spells such as Urza's Rage, and Misdirection provided blue a way to deal with these spells, even when tapped out. Gush gave blue a "free" card-drawing card, which worked very well when combined with Foil, or in decks which could play multiple lands a turn with Exploration. In fact, part of the problem with blue was that returning lands to your hand (blue’s alternate cost for the block) could often be exploited to an advantage!
For a very long time, Force of Will stood on the brink of being banned in the
Even with the problems with blue, the alternate play cost mechanic has proven to be one of the better ones, as a vast majority of the cards were playable in one constructed format or another (Extended, Type 2, or Block), and were very popular with the players. Judgment saw some alternate flashback costs (such as Battle Screech and Prismatic Strands), showing that R&D still has at least the spirit of APC cards in mind. I wouldn’t be at all surprised to see these types of cards making another appearance in the not horribly distant Magic future.
As a sidenote, I suppose it is possible to call Basking Rootwalla an APC card, since there is a way to get it into play that does not invlove mana. Imagine if it had the text "If you control a Wild Mongrel, you may play Basking Rootwalla without paying its mana cost." Almost the same thing. But here are the traditional APC cards:
|Alternate Playing Cost Cards|
|Alliances||Scars of the Veteran||Force of Will||Contagion||Pyrokinesis||Bounty of the Hunt|
|Mercadian Masques||Cho-Arrim Legate,