Mixing It Up

Posted in Serious Fun on December 11, 2007

By The Ferrett

Old_FogeyAlas, I am a fuddy-duddy. When people come around with their cool Magic variants, I just shake my head.

"No thanks," say I. "I like Free-For-All."

"What about some Two-Headed Giant?" they ask.

"I'm good."

"How about some 'attack left' multiplayer?"


"Do you want to do anything interesting at all?" they ask in startled disbelief.

"Nah," I say, and return to the format I love best.

But it's not fair; you poor readers shouldn't be held hostage to my stodgy habits. Many folks get off on the idea of bizarre Magic variants where the rules are changed to make life more interesting... and if you've been following my casual writings here at magicthegathering.com, you may not know about some of the best of them simply because I haven't mentioned them.

Well, it's time to rectify that. Here are some of the cooler Magic variants. Some of these, like Elder Dragon Highlander, are Constructed formats, where you have to bring a specially made deck... but others can be thrown together on the spur of the moment, or even just plopped down into the middle of your normal Magic game.

So here are some of my hand-picked variants to spice up your multiplayer group. Each of these are thoroughly Ferrett-approved.

Even if I am a stick-in-the-mud.

Chaos Magic

Grip_of_ChaosIf you delight in creating long-term plans and then carrying them out... Well, this format's not for you.

The rules of this format are pretty simple: Get a stack of various enchantments, instants, and sorceries that you think would make the game more interesting if they happened. This is called the Chaos Deck. Shuffle them up, and put them in a big ol' pile in the middle of the table.

Then, at the beginning of every player's upkeep, they roll a six-sided die. If that die comes up six, the top card of the Chaos Deck is flipped over—and you may not respond to its effect, since it does not use the stack—and the card then "comes into play." If it's a sorcery or an instant, it fires once and only once. If it's an enchantment or artifact, it affects everyone until it goes away.

You may not counter or Naturalize the Chaos Card. It as unstoppable as the tides. In fact, the only thing that can stop a Chaos Card is a new Chaos Card coming into play; the moment a new Chaos Card is flipped over, the old Chaos Card goes away.

The trick is, naturally, making a good Chaos deck. Cards like Wrath of God do the job, but they're not particularly interesting. Better to use something like Fecundity, which makes it more fun for everybody.

Also, to avoid rules issues, you'll usually want to pick cards that don't involve player interaction and do involve everyone. While it seems fun to have, say, a Goblin Bombardment into play, the obvious question is whether anyone can sacrifice a critter to do a point of damage. If it's just one guy, well, the luck factor starts to get obscene if he flips over something good and just wins. And if it's everyone, then people get confused because that's not what Goblin Bombardment says.

(Alternatively, you can try to engineer it so that any effect that says "you" means "any player," but that still gets messy. Better to stay away from it altogether.)

Here's a sample Chaos Magic deck:

Fecundity Evacuation Blood Moon Karona, False God
Dovescape Furnace of Rath Death Pits of Rath Kavu Lair
Æther Flash Bedlam Purify Oath of Druids
Æther Snap Thieves’ Auction Oppression Fade Away
Living Death Squeeze Planar Birth Tariff
Wildfire Underworld Dreams Mana Flare Eureka
Natural Balance City of Solitude Price of Glory Elephant Resurgence
Reduce to Dreams Pandemonium Lifeline Infernal Genesis

(Okay, I said no creatures. But Karona, False God is such fun in this stack....)

There are a lot of variants on this, of course. Some folks allow you to respond to a new Chaos Card coming into play. Others allow you to counter, Disenchant, or destroy it. And still others have even better stacks than this.

Regardless, it's a lot of fun. You have to be willing to ride with the punches, since your certain victory can be wiped away in an instant by the wrong card, and players who were once far behind will suddenly be boosted into the winner's seat. If you hate random effects, I wouldn't suggest it.

But c'mon. It's called Chaos Magic. What did you expect?

Elder Dragon Highlander

The interesting thing in casual Magic is that Constructed formats wax and wane for mysterious reasons. At one point, 5-Color seemed to be everywhere you looked—and then, almost as suddenly as it had arrived, it faded away. It's still around, of course—no Magic variant truly dies—but it's not nearly as popular as it once was.

The rise of Elder Dragon Highlander, however, is no surprise. It has an ambassador in the form of Level 5 Judge Sheldon Menery, who has gone to great lengths to export it to every Pro Tour and Grand Prix he arrives at. (And, as an extra-special bonus for me, it was created by two friends of mine in Anchorage.)

Nicol_BolasThere are a fair number of rules.... but fortunately, EDH is one of the most flavor-heavy Magic variants around. You'll find it pretty intuitive as long as you get that you're in command of a legendary general who's commanding his army.


  • Your deck is exactly 100 cards, and with the exception of basic lands, every card must be unique. (That's why it's "Highlander," chum—there can be only one.)
  • You must choose a legendary creature as the "general" of your deck. Your deck must contain one copy of this general—who else is going to lead the troops?

    (NOTE: As of 12/5/2007, Rofellos is banned as a general.)
  • No two players can have the same general. There are various rules involved in picking your general, depending on the group, but generally (heh) it's "first come, first served." Which makes sense; these generals are legendary, man.
  • The cards in your deck can only have mana symbols that appear in your general's mana cost. For example, if you choose Rith, the Awakener, you can only have cards with green, white, and red mana symbols in your deck. Any card with black or blue in the mana cost is right out; even though Wrecking Ball has red in its cost, it also has black—a forbidden color—so it can't be in your Rith deck. Elves of Deep Shadow and Momentary Blink are out as well. (Some groups have house rules to handle Thelon of Havenwood and other generals who would disqualify themselves under this rule.)
  • A deck may not generate mana outside of its general's colors, either. If you have a Birds of Paradise in your Rith deck, it can generate only green, white, red, and (since any "illegal" mana is considered colorless) colorless mana. Those generals are pretty strict about staying in flavor.
  • Each player starts at 40 life.
  • If you manage to do 21 points of combat damage to someone with your general, they lose. This damage can't be healed or undone.
  • At the beginning of each game, before shuffling, you remove your general from the game.
  • When your general is removed from the game, you may play it. As an additional cost, however, you must pay an extra two mana for every time you've played it before.
  • If a general would go to the graveyard, remove it from the game instead. (Generals can't die—they just fade away. Temporarily.)

EDH is played with Vintage-legal cards, with a smattering of officially banned cards; see the official page for the current details. Each group may have its own banned variants, though, and some cards have been "errataed" for EDH play.

(Full disclosure: I have yet to actually play EDH—I know, I know. But so many people have written in to extol the virtues of EDH that I felt it was about time I brought it up here in the hopes of supporting it.)

Type 4

Infinite_HourglassNobody likes being mana-screwed. So how would you like a game where you start with infinite mana in your deck? That's right; if you've got that spell in hand, you can cast it every time.

Well, that's Type 4 for you, a.k.a. "Limited Infinity." Like Chaos Magic, it involves a stack of cards that you create in advance – but unlike Chaos Magic, everyone drafts from this stack, creating a deck from their best picks. (Also, to prevent abuse, you can only play one spell per turn.)

I'd say more, but Stephen Menendian wrote about it here, and since that's about the best introduction to a format that I've ever read, there's not much more I can add. Type Four always been a hoot the regrettably few times I've played it, and I can't recommend it highly enough.

The only slightly tricky thing is developing a good stack, as Stephen notes. Fortunately, many people have been kind enough to share their advice on creating the most enjoyable and strategic T4 stacks; you can try here and here and here and here.


Magic: The Roleplaying Game


Intrepid_HeroAbe Sargent has been one of the stalwarts of the Casual Magic community, chronicling rare and obscure formats for over two hundred articles now. (Seriously. Check his archives.) But a couple of weeks ago, he came out with what seemed like a truly fun idea: Magic the RPG .

That's right; if you're familiar with Dungeons and Dragons, you'll get the gist of it right away. You choose a name for your "character," and you start with twelve Mage points. You then use your Mage points to give your character "stats" and "skills."

There are two stats: Physical Fortitude governs your starting life, and you begin with five points of life for each Mage point you put into Physical Fortitude.

Mental Fortitude represents your memory—a.k.a. "cards in hand." Every Mage point you put into Mental Fortitude allows you to start an additional card. (Most players will probably choose to put seven Mage points into this to start with the traditional seven cards.)

The skills, however, are where the coolness is. Abe has listed a bunch of skills that you can spend Mage points on to use in the game, many of which caused hot debates in the forums about which skills were too powerful or too weak. Since this variant only emerged a few weeks ago, it's not clear what's what yet, so some tweaking will undoubtedly be needed.

But the cool thing is that as you play more games in the format, you grow in power and move up the XP chart—just like D&D. Wouldn't you like to be a fifth-level player? Of course you would.

I think it's a clever variant. I haven't had time to play it, natch, but the sheer number of ways you can change up things seems like it'd be a lot of fun. I encourage you to try it out, since I'd like to see if this neato idea is ready for prime time.

Other Formats

Doubling_CubeThere are a host of awesome formats for you to try, if you'd like – this just skims the surface. There's Cube Draft (which is amazingly fun when you draft a Mox), Peasant Magic, Rainbow Stairwell, Mental Magic, Secret Alliances, and of course Magic Online fan favorites Tribal and Prismatic and Vanguard and Donner and Blitzen. (Click here for the list of official Constructed formats.)

There are a lot of ways to mix up your Magic. Delve deep, if you're so inclined!

Latest Serious Fun Articles


January 5, 2016

Hedron Alignment by, Bruce Richard

When I first looked at my preview card, I couldn't really wrap my brain around it. The card does so much that I wasn't really understanding its value. Kind of a "forest for the trees" thi...

Learn More


December 29, 2015

Eternal Pilgrim by, Bruce Richard

When religious belief turns into religious fervor, things get problematic—particularly on Zendikar. When the Eldrazi were originally imprisoned, stories were told to ensure no one would t...

Learn More



Serious Fun Archive

Consult the archives for more articles!

See All