Reign of Silumgar

Posted in Top Decks on April 17, 2015

By Luis Scott-Vargas

Luis Scott-Vargas plays, writes, and makes videos about Magic. He has played on the Pro Tour for almost a decade, and between that and producing content for ChannelFireball, often has his hands full (of cards).

Pro Tour Dragons of Tarkir lived up to its name. Almost every deck in the Top 8 had Dragons (or in the case of the winner, followed Atarka's Commands faithfully), and the breakout deck of the Pro Tour is as Dragon-focused as it gets. That deck is what I want to talk about today, because our Dragon overlords have landed, and they are ready to take over.

Dragonlord Silumgar | Art by Steven Belledin

Before we address the Dragonlord's Prerogatives, let's take a look at what all made it to the Top 8.

As promised, that's a lot of Dragons. Most notably, the deck with the largest number of copies is Blue-Black Control, which coincidentally is the deck I think emerged looking best from the Pro Tour. There are two distinct builds of the deck in the Top 8, and I want to start from the least number of Dragons and work my way up.

Adrian Sullivan's Blue-Black Control — Pro Tour Dragons of Tarkir

Download Arena Decklist

This is the "standard" Blue-Black list, and looks remarkably similar to what Blue-Black lists have looked like ever since Pro Tour Khans. Adrian, in particular, has played this list or something very close to it for months. And his approach to this Pro Tour was to tune his deck with the new cards, but keep it fundamentally the same.

The deck is fairly simple, despite the abundance of 1 and 2-ofs.

27 land

17 removal spells (Bile Blight, Perilous Vault, etc)

5 counterspells (Dissolve and Dissipate)

6 card draw spells (Dig Through Time, Jace's Ingenuity, and Dragonlord's Prerogative)

5 Planeswalkers (Ashiok, Ugin, and Liliana)

That's it. The deck just wants to survive by killing or countering threats, draw cards, and proceed to win the game as slowly as possible. While I can get behind that strategy, I think the way the other Blue-Black lists were configured offers a more powerful alternative, and one with more Dragons.

Here are three different takes on the deck, two from the Top 8 and one that Team ChannelFireball played (with Paulo Vitor damo da Rosa and Josh Utter-Leyton making Top 16 with, going a combined 17-3).

Andrew Ohlschwa's Blue-Black Control — Pro Tour Dragons of Tarkir

Download Arena Decklist

Shota Yasooka's Blue-Black Control — Pro Tour Dragons of Tarkir

Download Arena Decklist

Team ChannelFireball's Esper Dragons

Download Arena Decklist

These three lists are all based around a similar engine, one that would not have been possible prior to Dragons of Tarkir.

If you look at what these cards do when the Dragon cost is paid, they are absurd. Counterspell is a card that hasn't been legal in Standard for over 10 years, and Diabolic Edict plus gain 4 life is incredibly crushing against aggro, so figuring out how many Dragons you can play and you want to play is the real question. It is important to note that both Silumgar's Scorn and Foul-Tongue Invocation work without a Dragon, and I'd expect Scorn to counter most things up until turn five or so without any incident, which plays a key role in making sure this deck functions even when Dragons are absent.

Here's our own Dragon counter, when looking at different Blue-Black Control lists:

Ohlschwager: 8

Yasooka: 6

Team ChannelFireball: 5

These Dragons all came from the following pool:

There are two main things to consider when deciding how many Dragons to play in this deck. It is clearly important to have some number, as enabling Silumgar's Scorn is critical, but how many is just as important to figure out.

  1. How much of a cost is it to play these cards? These four Dragons are clearly powerful, but if it weren't for the Dragon bonus that Scorn represents, these decks would play way fewer of them (or in the case of Ojutai, avoid playing a third color).
  2. What percentage are you comfortable with when it comes to seeing a Dragon by a specific turn?

The answer to the first question is trickier, because the only way to arrive there is some combination of playtesting and theorycrafting, and there's no clean answer. I can speak to the conclusion that Team ChannelFireball came to, which is that the hexproof Dragons they played did not compromise the deck's immunity to removal spells, and were close enough to what the deck wanted that they were worth playing to power up Scorn and Invocation (and Prerogative, to some extent). They would play zero if not for those cards, but playing the Dragons was not adding unplayable cards to the deck, by any stretch.

The second question can be approximated a little easier, at least in terms of knowing what the percentages are for each number of Dragons. Deciding which you are comfortable with is, again, more guesswork/intuition/theory than any hard-and-fast rule, but you can at least get a rough idea of what your odds are of having a Dragon at a certain point.

The Odds of Having One or More Dragons by Turn 5 (12 cards into library)

With 5 Dragons: 68.64%

With 6 Dragons: 75.48%

With 7 Dragons: 80.93%

With 8 Dragons: 85.25%

(While not quite as exact as Frank Karsten's calculations, I used a hypergeometric calculation with the parameters of a population of 60, successes in population from 5-8, and sample size 12)

There's a pretty big range here, with the adventurous members of Team ChannelFireball being the most willing to risk having no Dragons in-hand at a much higher rate than Andrew Ohlschwager, and to a lesser extent, Shota. Anticipate does help increase the odds, though Ohlschwager again leads the pack there, with the full four in his deck. He was not willing to ever be caught without a Dragon, and his decklist reflects that.

As for which number is correct, that I cannot say with certainty. Playing the minimum of 5 Dragons worked out well for those who played it, and 68% plus Anticipate and scry lands does not seem excessively risky. It is also true that Invocation works without backup, and sometimes Silumgar's Scorn is live even much later than turn five as a Force Spike. I'd lean toward the 5-6 range, and don't think you need to go all the way up to 8 like Ohlschwager did. The biggest incentive to no go above 5 is that you get to play all hexproof Dragons and blank opposing removal. Both Shota and Ohlschwager had numerous targets for removal, and I don't like that it makes opposing Hero's Downfalls and the like into live cards instead of dead ones.

The Rest of the Deck

Besides the Dragons and their attendant spells, the deck is split up much like Adrian Sullivan's. It's full of removal and card draw, with the counterspells and finishers taken care of via the Dragon package.

Another big incentive to play the Dragon version of the deck is how much better Crux of Fate is. It is true that Crux can backfire against opposing Dragons, but it's awesome how powerful it is to cast Crux to wipe everything but the Dragon you have in play. Plague Wind is a nice card, and getting to cast it for five mana is even nicer.

All of these cards play specific roles, and splitting them up helps give you a range of answers to every potential threat. It is nice that Ojutai and Silumgar can hunt down Planeswalkers, but even so it's important to have Hero's Downfall as an unconditional removal spell. The mana cost on Bile Blight is tough, but the card has so much value against tokens and early plays that it demands inclusion. Lastly, Ultimate Price kills all sorts of large green monsters, but is the most narrow, and you can't jam tons into your deck without running into problems.

Four Dig is mandatory, and is even better in this deck than other versions of Blue-Black. Anticipate and Silumgar's Scorn are both cheap spells that fuel Dig, and Anticipate can even find it. I include Prerogative because some members of the team played one main, and the sideboarded copies were incredibly important. Because of the Dragons, this is an un-counterable Opportunity in control matchups, which is as insane as it sounds.

How to Fight This Deck

This deck is great against much of the field, but is by no means unbeatable, and Martin Dang has a Pro Tour trophy that shows just that. He had the best deck in the Top 8 against Blue-Black, and defeated two different copies of it on the way to his win.

Martin Dang's Red Aggro — Pro Tour Dragons of Tarkir

Download Arena Decklist

If Blue-Black control is a finely-tuned machine, one where the percentages of drawing Dragons is carefully calculated and the mix of removal is critical, Red Aggro is the hammer that smashes that machine, as the Top 8 amply demonstrated. As it turns out, playing one-drop into two-drop into burn spells is very good against a deck full of five-plus-drops with a bunch of lands that enter the battlefield tapped.

Martin burned down the competition, and it wasn't particularly close. The matchup isn't unwinnable for Blue-Black, but it is tough, even with an extensive sideboard plan. The fact of the matter is, blue and black just don't have enough cards that change the matchup drastically, even if they wanted to board in 8 or so. Some combination of Drown in Sorrow and Pharika's Cure seems like the best bet, but in game two against Dang, Adrian Sullivan played a removal spell on turns two through five and still lost a long game.

If I had to choose a deck to play in a tournament tomorrow, I'd play Blue-Black Dragons close to the CFB list. Even if Red Aggro is tough, matchups against the rest of the field are solid, and Red Aggro isn't likely to be more than 20-25% of the field. If you want to beat Blue-Black, Red Aggro is clearly the best choice, and if you want to beat Red Aggro, I'd look at playing something like the Green-Red Devotion decks that made Top 8. There are tons of other viable decks too, decks like Abzan Aggro/Control, Jeskai Tokens, Red-Green Dragons, and more. Standard is your oyster, and just because I favor cracking that oyster with powerful Dragons doesn't mean that's the only way.


Latest Top Decks Articles


August 2, 2018

Team Trios Constructed at the Pro Tour – Modern and Legacy by, Simon Görtzen

Pro Tour 25th Anniversary Coverage Begins Today! Tune in to for four days of Pro Tour coverage celebrating Magic's 25th Anniversary, beginning TODAY (August 2) at 2 p.m. ...

Learn More


July 31, 2018

Team Trios Constructed at the Pro Tour – Standard by, Simon Görtzen

Tomorrow, I'll board a plane to Minneapolis, Minnesota, to cover Pro Tour 25th Anniversary. On Thursday, August 2, the $150,000 Silver Showcase kicks off the action with a once-in-a-lifet...

Learn More



Top Decks Archive

Consult the archives for more articles!

See All