Back to the Grind

Posted in The Week That Was on August 12, 2005

By Brian David-Marshall

Brian David-Marshall is a New York–based game designer who has been involved with Magic since 1994, when he started organizing tournaments and ran a Manhattan game store. Since then, he has been a judge, a player, and one of the longest-tenured columnists on, as he enters his second decade writing for the site. He is also the Pro Tour Historian and one of the commentators for the Pro Tour.

Last weekend it was dumplings at the night market in Taipei and this weekend it is crab cakes from the Inner Harbor in Maryland. Hot on the heels of Grand Prix-Taipei, I am working this weekend as part of the coverage team for U.S. Nationals in Baltimore. So what should you be expecting to see this weekend?

The stage is set for U.S. Nationals 2005.

It is easy to think of U.S. Nationals as the All-Star Game of American Magic, but that has never been an apt label. If you look back at the U.S. National teams over the past decade you will see that Nats is more like a Future Stars showcase than the Mid-summer classic.

If you took me literally and went over to the newly revamped Tournament Center and strolled through past National teams, you will probably think I am insane as the teams are liberally sprinkled with the likes of Mark Justice, Mike Long, Jon Finkel, Bob Maher, Jr., Justin Gary, Aaron Forsythe, Eugene Harvey, Kyle Rose, and so on. But if you go back and look at all of those players' respective careers, you will see that their first Nationals team appearances marked the beginning of the ascendancy of their careers.

Historically if there is a big name and "some guy" in the Top 8 of U.S. Nationals, you should lay money on Mr. Guy. Past actors playing the role of Mr. Guy include Maher, Gary, Forsythe, Harvey, and Gabe Walls. Of course the person who originated that role was Hall of Fame Inductee Jon Finkel – the only member of the inaugural class to represent the United States at the World Championships.

That is not entirely true… by the time Jon was part of the winning U.S. National team at Worlds 1998, he had already accomplished quite a bit. It was during the previous year's Nationals that Jon first drew attention as a serious future star, even though he fell one match shy of making the Top 8 that year.

Eugene Harvey was once a 'some guy' at U.S. Nationals.Jon got into Nationals that year via the “meatgrinders” – the unpleasant name for the single-elimination tournaments that take place on-site the day before each National Championship. After grinding in with his blue-white deck Jon went on to sweep the draft portion of the competition.

I think that might have been the first year that Grinders were incorporated into the Nationals schedule, which makes Jon one of the first players to ever accomplish that feat. One of the most recent players to accomplish that is Mike McGee, who was one of four players to earn a berth at this year's event via the midnight meat grinder Wednesday night.

McGee is a former JSS star who received press two years ago when he played in Day One of Nationals despite being eligible for the JSS Championships that would commence the following day. McGee got off to a torrid 6-0 start and the room was abuzz about the undefeated player who was going to drop to play in the JSS.

In the end, McGee skipped the JSS and went on to finish 22nd, winning $350. He was playing for the Top 8 with two rounds to go when his Top 8 chances were derailed by eventual National Team member Gabe Walls.

Mike McGee braved the Midnight grinder to qualify for Nationals.
“I don't regret it all,” recalled McGee when asked if ever regretted passing up the ostensibly easier money of the JSS. “The experience was really valuable – I mean, the money was fine too – but I don't regret it at all.”

McGee has not played much Magic over the past year as he prepared to graduate High School. With school behind him he has turned his focus back toward Magic and was ready and raring to go at Midnight for the first chance at a last chance qualifier. It was not a long trip for the McGee household as they live only a couple of hours away in New Jersey.

“Now that school is over I want to get back into it. I came here because, well…it's a tournament and event,” McGee explained with a chuckle. “Even if I didn't grind in, I figured there would still be PTQs and stuff to do.”

“I played a mono-red list that I got from one of the European Nationals Top 8s – actually a friend gave me the list,” McGee said, referring to Justin Morcate who also qualified in the same grinder. “The deck looked like it would be good against red agro and rats with a favorable 60/40 matchup against Tooth. "

Although McGee said that there were plenty of Mountains at the top tables in his tournament, he is not expecting that to be the most prevalent deck when Nationals kicks off.

“There will be more Tooth and Blue Tron than there are red decks – but those are the three best decks for Standard.”

Mike McGee - Mono-Red

Download Arena Decklist

Justin Morcate - Mono-Red

Download Arena Decklist

David Sharfman - Tooth and Nail

Download Arena Decklist

Semion Bezrukov - Medium Green

Download Arena Decklist

There were plenty of familiar faces around the hall, ranging from the expected Regionals winners to past National team members like Walls. One of the most unexpected faces belonged to a member of last year's National Team – the Dutch National Team, that is. Jeroen Remie has started laying the groundwork for his 2006 Invitational campaign for the Road Warrior ballot by hanging out in Baltimore this weekend, and joked with Randy Buehler about trying to find a way to play this weekend.

“Hey Randy, can I play as William Jensen?”

Gen Con Vintage Championship prize

Draw One Card...

That was artist Mark Poole's job for this year's Vintage Championship. The text on the card he was hired to draw? Target player draws three cards. That's right, the prize for this year's Gen Con Vintage Championship will be a piece of original art that re-imagines the best card-drawing spell ever printed, Ancestral Recall. Past prizes have included a newly painted Chris Rush Black Lotus and a fresh Mark Tedin take on Time Walk.

Scott Larabee took this year's prize one step beyond merely crafting a new piece of art.

“I took the original painting and had our graphic designer Matt Stevens – in proportion – mock up a new card frame so it would look like a current card that is about 15 inches by 12 inches. The flavor text says ‘2005 Vintage Champion', the collector number is 1 of 9, and the expansion symbol is the Vintage Championships logo. It's pretty cool.”

The event is next week at Gen Con alongside a host of other cool events like Two-Headed Giant Championship and Legacy Championship. Keep your eyes peeled for feature articles breaking down the two Eternal Championships in the Tournament Center in the near future. Ted “Type 1” Knutson will be covering Vintage while Zvi Mowshowitz will be playing in the Legacy event – his last sanctioned event before taking his R&D position – and writing about his experience.

Latest The Week That Was Articles


January 8, 2016

Five Formats in the New Year by, Brian David-Marshall

Two-Headed Giant | Booster Draft | ModernStandard | Canadian Highlander | Player of the Month The sweet sound of Oath of the Gatewatch packs getting cracked will make its way around th...

Learn More


January 1, 2016

Oath of Nissa by, Brian David-Marshall

Do you remember back when blue got all the fun toys? Now, you might think I am talking about cards like Force of Will or Control Magic, but I am actually thinking a little smaller—a lot s...

Learn More



The Week That Was Archive

Consult the archives for more articles!

See All