You Make the Card #3 - Wrap-up

Posted in Feature on January 25, 2006

By Mark Rosewater

Working in R&D since '95, Mark became Magic head designer in '03. His hobbies: spending time with family, writing about Magic in all mediums, and creating short bios.

We're done!

Starting almost a year ago (and yes, we're making plans to ensure You Make the Card #4 has a much tighter schedule), we've had nine steps and six votes. The last one was on the card's flavor text and here's how it went:

Which should be the flavor text for Vanish Into Memory?
Out of sight, into mind. 5458 24.0%
Its absence brings wealth, and sadness;
Its return, both joy and madness.
3115 13.7%
"Death is a hero's first step to immortality." - Boros Drill Master 2766 12.2%
A dream is just a reality vanished into memory. A reality is a dream come true. 2689 11.8%
"Knowledge manifested from power, memory vanished from weakness...." 2641 11.6%
A memory is what is left when something happens and doesn't completely unhappen. 1485 6.5%
"Shut eyes memorize; open eyes mesmerize." - Wizard's incantation 1457 6.4%
Which do you choose; fleeting valor or wisdom soon unremembered? 1418 6.2%
...and emerge as possibility. 961 4.2%
The trick is not to find treasure in the mind, but to keep it with open eyes. 723 3.2%
Total 22713 100.0%

And that means that Out of sight, into mind is our winner.

The winning flavor text was submitted by Thomas Lefler. And Mike Lose. And also Tim Ebert, as well as Robinson Mead and somebody who goes by just "Chris." Congratulations to all five of them.

As a special treat for finishing this incarnation of You Make the Card, I thought I'd treat you with the first preview card from the Coldsnap expansion coming out. Click here to see it.

Vanish Into Memory

Yes, Vanish Into Memory has been slotted for Coldsnap. And just between you and me, the fact that the entire readership of came up word for word (and art for art) with a card the Ice Age designers made over a decade ago only to be misplaced in Richard Garfield's file cabinet for ten years is staggering. Staggering! (You all seem okay with the brain in the jar running R&D so work with me here.)

I think you guys did an excellent job and I'm excited to see what happens when Vanish Into Memory finally sees print. Once again, good job!

Mark Rosewater

Latest Feature Articles


July 11, 2019

Magic at San Diego Comic-Con 2019! by, Wizards of the Coast

Fans, creators, and some of the biggest names in entertainment are descending on San Diego now for Comic-Con, and so are we! If you're in town for the convention, be sure to swing by the ...

Learn More


July 2, 2019

Core Set 2020 Prerelease Primer by, Gavin Verhey

Old favorites. New pals. Lots of Chandra in your face everywhere. That can only mean one thing: it's time for Core Set 2020! Whether you're new to slinging spells or a seasoned Planeswal...

Learn More



Feature Archive

Consult the archives for more articles!

See All

We use cookies on this site to personalize content and ads, provide social media features and analyze web traffic. By clicking YES, you are consenting for us to set cookies. (Learn more about cookies)

No, I want to find out more