One of our hopes for the Magic Rules Blog is to go behind the scenes of why and how some rules change. When Magic: The Gathering® | The Hobbit™ released, we updated the rules for what counts as a mana ability.

Prior to the change, an activated ability was a mana ability if it met the following criteria:

  • It doesn't require a target.
  • It can add mana to a player's mana pool when it resolves.
  • It is not a loyalty ability.

Activated mana abilities are special: They can be activated whenever a player has priority and whenever a spell, ability, rule, or effect requires a mana payment. They also don't use the stack. When you activate a mana ability while casting a spell, its mana needs to be available to pay for that spell right away, before any player would receive priority and before a typical activated ability could resolve.

Aetherworks Marvel Lightning Strike Thalia, Guardian of Thraben Millikin

Resolving abilities while casting a spell can cause some weird things to happen. Suppose you activate your Aetherworks Marvel and see a Lightning Strike among the top six cards. Your opponent has a Thalia, Guardian of Thraben, so you will need to pay to cast your Lightning Strike. You activate your trusty Millikin to get that mana and … Wait, what card should you mill? Technically, the cards you look at from the top of your library when you activate Aetherworks Marvel do not change zones. They are still on top of your library while you look at them and while you cast your Lightning Strike. The Lightning Strike you started casting has already been moved to the stack (that happens right away when you attempt to cast a spell), but the other five cards you looked at are technically still in your library and in the same order. But do you remember which of those five remaining cards should have been on top? Most players don't maintain the order of the cards they search from the top of their library, so this becomes an awkward problem.

Panglacial Wurm

With Panglacial Wurm, you also need to keep track of the order of your library while you search it. Suppose you activate Evolving Wilds and search your library. When you do, you decide you'd like to cast your Panglacial Wurm. If you try to use your Chromatic Sphere to pay the mana cost of Panglacial Wurm, you now need to draw a card while casting Panglacial Wurm and searching your library.

Selvala, Explorer Returned Future Sight

Selvala, Explorer Returned created even weirder cases. Suppose you have Future Sight in play and would like to cast a Grizzly Bears from the top of your library. You put it on the stack, then activate Selvala to (maybe) get some mana. You and your opponent each reveal the top card of your libraries, then you each draw those cards. Unfortunately for your Grizzly Bears, only one player revealed a nonland card, so you only generate one and cannot pay the mana cost of Grizzly Bears. Because Selvala's ability includes drawing a card, the mana ability cannot be reversed, so you simply put the Grizzly Bears back on top of your library, having drawn the card beneath it with Selvala's ability.

Elvish Spirit Guide

This can get even weirder if the card you reveal and draw from Selvala's ability is an Elvish Spirit Guide, because cards drawn during the casting of spells are drawn face down. So even though you revealed that the card you drew is an Elvish Spirit Guide, and even though it is in your hand and you can still activate mana abilities, you cannot use Elvish Spirit Guide to pay for your Grizzly Bears. After returning Grizzly Bears to the top of your library and turning the card in your hand face up, you can then use the Elvish Spirit Guide to get the extra mana you need, alongside the floating mana from Selvala's ability, to cast the Grizzly Bears. But you would have to restart the casting process to get to that point.

Technically, these situations all work in the rules and have answers, but those answers don't line up with how players typically use their cards. Few players keep their cards in order while searching their library or looking at the top cards of their library, and even fewer players keep a close enough eye on their opponent's searching to verify which cards should be on top. Part of the job of the Rules team is to make sure that the rules work not just in theory but also for how players actually play Magic.

To clean up these rules, we added a criterion for which activated abilities are mana abilities:

  • Its cost and effect don't move any card to or from a library.

Now, activated abilities like those of Chromatic Sphere; Millikin; and Selvala, Explorer Returned are no longer considered mana abilities. That means they can only be activated at instant speed (not during the casting or activating process of other spells or abilities), and they use the stack. We added reminder text to the impacted cards and also to cards with other abilities that look like mana abilities but aren't, like Deathrite Shaman.

In addition to making rules mirror how players actually play, the Rules team tries to create rules that players can readily understand and follow. Making mana abilities easy to identify is just as important as cleaning up their rules corner cases. For that reason, the new criterion looks only at the text on the card itself and doesn't take replacement effects or other variables into account. That means that you can still get up to some shenanigans with the right replacement effects (I'm looking at you, Nefarious Lich), but it is harder to do so and won't come up nearly as often.

This change to mana abilities is an example of one of the broader projects of the Rules team. A lot of our work focuses on cards and mechanics that are in development and will release soon. Occasionally, we also identify confusing or problematic sections of the existing rules. When we do, we investigate whether there are ways to improve or fix those rules and evaluate (with the help of other teams) the impact of potential changes on existing cards and Magic formats. In this case, we found a change that affected relatively few cards, mostly in confusing and unintended scenarios, and greatly reduced the chances of players running into these scenarios by accident.


Read more about the Rules Management team and the rules of Magic in our introduction to the Magic Rules Blog.